SCR 12-10
SUPREME COURT RULES AND ORDERS
IN THE MATTER OF THE REVISION OF THE
STANDARD PARENTING GUIDELINES
PURSUANT TO SDCL 25-4A-10 RULE 12-10
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
This matter having first come before the Court at the August 2011 rules hearing, and the
court having considered the proposed revisions to the standard guidelines as required in SDCL 25-4A-10, and the Court having made further changes to these guidelines, now, therefore, it is
ORDERED that the revised South Dakota Parenting Guidelines are approved by the Court
on unanimous vote by all the justices, and it is further,
ORDERED that these South Dakota Parenting Guidelines be promulgated in accordance
with the law.
of the parenting schedule. If the parents are unable to agree on their own Parenting Plan, however,
these Guidelines become mandatory and will be used as their Parenting Plan. SDCL 25-4A-10,
25-4A-11. In the event a parent's time with the children becomes an issue in court, the judge will
set whatever Parenting Plan best meets the needs of the children.
1. GENERAL RULES.
A parent must always avoid speaking negatively about the other parent and must firmly
discourage such conduct by relatives or friends. Each parent should speak in positive terms about
the other parent in the presence of the children. Each parent must encourage the children to respect
the other parent. Children should never be used by one parent to spy or report on the other parent.
The basic rules of conduct and discipline established by the custodial parent should be the baseline
standard for both parents and any step-parents, and consistently enforced by all caregivers, so that
the children do not receive mixed messages.
Children will benefit from continued contact with all relatives and friends on both sides of
the family for whom they feel affection. Such relationships must be protected and encouraged. But
relatives, like parents, need to avoid being critical of either parent in front of the children. Parents
should have their children maintain ties with both the maternal and paternal relatives. Usually the
children will visit the paternal relatives during times when the children are with their father and
the maternal relatives during times when they are with their mother.
In cases where both parents reside in the same community at the time of separation, and
then one parent leaves the area, thus changing the Parenting Plan, the court will consider imposing
on the parent who moved the travel costs for the children necessary to facilitate future time with
the children; however, the court will also consider other factors such as the economic
circumstances of the parents and the reasons prompting the move. Before relocating the children,
the custodial parent is required to comply with South Dakota's statutory forty-five-day written
notice requirements. SDCL 25-4A-17.
1.1 Parental Communication. Parents must always keep each other advised of their home and
work addresses and telephone numbers. Whenever feasible, all communication concerning the
children must be conducted directly between the parents in person, or by telephone, or at their
residences, or via email or text message. Absent an emergency, communication should not occur
at a parent's place of employment.
1.2 Grade Reports and Medical Information. The custodial parent must provide the noncustodial parent with the name, address, and telephone number of the school where any child attends and must authorize the noncustodial parent to communicate concerning the child directly with the school and with the child's doctors and other professionals, outside the presence of the custodial parent. The noncustodial parent also has an obligation to contact the school to ensure receipt of school report cards, notices, etc., so that he/she can remain involved with their child's education. Both parents will be listed on all of the child's records. Each parent must immediately notify the other parent of any medical emergencies or serious illnesses of a child. Access to records and information pertaining to a minor child, including, but not limited to, medical, dental, orthodontia and similar health care, and school records must be made equally available to both parents. Counseling, psychiatric, psychotherapy, and other records subject to confidentiality or privilege must only be released in accordance with state and federal law; but, if available to one parent, must be available to both. The parents must make reasonable efforts to ensure that the name and address of the other parent is listed on all such records. If the child is taking medications, the custodial parent must provide a sufficient amount and appropriate instructions. If either parent enrolls the child in any social, beneficent, religious, or peer group activity, service, benefit, or program for which written application is required, the enrolling parent must provide the name and address of the other parent on, or supplementary to, the application. [This provision does not apply to insurance or annuities.] The parent enrolling the child shall advise the other parent of the name of the coach, director, and organization providing the activity along with their contact information.
The custodial parent must notify the noncustodial parent of all school or other events (for example,
church and sports) involving parental participation. The noncustodial parent also has an obligation
to contact the activity director to ensure receipt of information such as practice schedules, games,
etc.
1.3 Clothing. The custodial parent will send an appropriate supply of children's clothing with the
children, which must be returned clean (when reasonably possible) with the children by the
noncustodial parent. The noncustodial parent must advise, as far in advance as possible, of any
special activities so that appropriate clothing belonging to the children may be sent. It is
recommended that the noncustodial parent have some basic clothing available in his/her home to
ensure that all of the children's basic needs are met.
1.4 Withholding Support or Time With the Children. Neither time with the children nor child
support is to be withheld because of either parent's failure to comply with a court order. Only the
court may enter sanctions for noncompliance. Children have a right both to support and, absent
abuse or other safety concerns, time with the noncustodial parent, neither of which is dependent
upon the other. In other words, no support does not mean the children will spend no time with the
noncustodial parent, and no time with the noncustodial parent does not mean no support needs to
be paid to the custodial parent. If there is a violation of either the parenting order or a support
order, the exclusive remedy is to apply to the court for appropriate sanctions.
1.5 Adjustments in Parenting Plan. Although this is a specific schedule, the parents are expected
to fairly modify the Parenting Plan when family necessities, illnesses, or commitments reasonably
so require. The requesting parent must act in good faith and give as much notice as circumstances
permit.
1.6 Parent's Vacation with Children. Unless otherwise specified in a court order or agreed upon
by the parents, each parent is entitled to a vacation with the children for a reasonable period of
time, usually equal. The custodial parent should plan a vacation during the time when the other
parent is not scheduled to spend time with the children. Parents are encouraged to coordinate
vacation plans.
1.7 Insurance Forms. The parent who has medical insurance coverage on the children must
supply to the other parent an insurance card and, as applicable, insurance forms and a list of
insurer-approved or HMO-qualified health care providers in the area where the other parent is
residing. Except in emergencies, the parent taking the children to a doctor, dentist, or other
provider not so approved or qualified may be required to pay the additional cost thus created.
However, when there is a change in insurance, which requires a change in medical care providers
and a child has a chronic illness, thoughtful consideration should be given by the parents to what
is more important, i.e., allowing the child to remain with the original provider or the economic
consequences of changing carriers. When there is an obligation to pay medical expenses, the parent
responsible for paying must be promptly furnished with the bill, and where applicable, the
explanation of benefits, by the other parent. The parents must cooperate in submitting bills to the
appropriate insurance carrier. Thereafter, the parent responsible for paying the balance of the bill
must make arrangements directly with the health care provider and will inform the other parent of
such arrangements. Insurance refunds must be promptly turned over to the parent who paid the bill
for which the refund was received.
1.8 Child Support Abatement. Unless a court order otherwise provides, child support will not
abate during any period when the children are with the noncustodial parent. South Dakota law
allows for child support abatements and offsets under certain circumstances. See generally SDCL
25-7. However, no abatement or offset may be taken unless there is a court order authorizing it.
1.9 Noncustodial Parent's Missed Time With the Children. When scheduled time with the children cannot occur due to events beyond either parent's control, such as illness of the parent exercising time with the children, then a mutually agreeable substituted date will be arranged, as
quickly as possible. Each parent must timely advise the other parent when scheduled time with the
children cannot be exercised. Missed time with the children must not be unreasonably
accumulated.
1.10 Children of Different Ages. Except with very young children and adolescents, it usually
makes sense for all the children to share the same schedule of parenting time with the noncustodial
parent. Having brothers or sisters along can be an important support for children. Infants have
special needs that may well prevent a parent from being with both the infant and the older children
at the same time. Teenagers' special needs for peer involvement and for some control of their own
lives may place them on different schedules from their younger brothers and sisters. Because it is
intended that the noncustodial parent's time with the children be a shared experience between
siblings and, unless these guidelines, a court order, or circumstances such as age, illness, or a
particular event suggests otherwise, all the children should participate together in spending time
with the noncustodial parent.
1.11. Communication with Children. Either parent may call, text, email, or Skype (or use similar
technology) to communicate with the children at reasonable times and with reasonable frequency
during those periods the children are with the other parent. The children may, of course, call, text,
email, or Skype (or use similar technology) to communicate with either parent, at reasonable hours
and with reasonable frequencies. Parents are cautioned that communication between the parent and
the children should not be so excessive as to interfere with the other parent's time, nor used to
undermine the other parent's authority. During long vacations, the parent with whom the children
are on vacation is required to make the children available for telephone calls with the other parent
at least every three days. At all other times, the parent the children are with must not refuse to
answer the other parent's telephone calls or turn off the telephone in order to deny the other parent
telephone contact. If a parent uses an answering machine or cell phone voicemail, messages left
should be returned by a telephone call to that parent as soon as possible. Parents should agree on
a specified time for calls to the children so that the children will be made available. A parent may
wish to provide an older child with a cell phone to facilitate these communications. In such
instances, it is not appropriate for a parent to use restrictions from talking to the other parent on
that cell phone as a means of punishing the child. Communication between a parent and child must
not be censored, recorded, or monitored, absent a court order. With older children, establishing an
email account for communication with the other parent is recommended and should likewise not
be read or monitored by the other parent without court permission. Email communication or text
messaging between parents is also helpful in keeping the other parent informed about the children.
Abuse, neglect, criminal activity, or protection orders may impact access to information regarding
the custodial parent or the children.
1.12 Other Contact. Parents have an unrestricted right to send cards, letters, packages, audio and
video cassettes, CDs, or similar items, to their children. Children also have the same right to send
items to their parents. Neither parent will interfere with this right. A parent may wish to provide
the children with self-addressed, stamped envelopes for the children's use in corresponding with
that parent.
1.13 Privacy of Residence. A parent may not enter the residence of the other parent except by
express invitation of the resident parent, regardless of whether a parent retains a property interest
in the residence. The children must be picked up at and returned to the front entrance of the other
parent's residence. The parent dropping off the children must not leave until the children are safely
inside the other parent's residence. Parents must refrain from surprise visits to the other parent's
home. A parent's time with the children is his/her own, and the children's time with the other parent
is equally private.
1.14 Special Considerations for Adolescents. While children never get to choose where they live, within reason, the parents should honestly and fairly consider their teenager's wishes on time with a parent. Neither parent should attempt to pressure their teenager to make a decision on time with
a parent adverse to the other parent. Teenagers should explain the reasons for their wishes directly
to the affected parent, without intervention by the other parent.
1.15 Day Care Providers. When parents reside in the same community, they should use the same
day care provider. To the extent feasible, the parents should rely on each other to care for the
children when the other parent is unavailable.
1.16 Special Circumstances:
A. Child Abuse. When child abuse has been established and a continuing danger is shown
to exist, all time with the abusive parent must cease or only be allowed under supervision,
depending on the circumstances. Court intervention is usually required in child abuse
cases.
B. Domestic Abuse. Witnessing domestic abuse has long-term, emotionally detrimental
effects on children. A person who loses control and acts impulsively with the other parent
may be capable of doing so with children as well. Depending on the nature of the spousal
abuse and when it occurred, the court may require an abusive parent to successfully
complete appropriate counseling before being permitted unsupervised time with the
children.
C. Substance Abuse. Time with the children must not occur when a parent is abusing
substances.
D. Long Interruption of Contact. In those situations where the noncustodial parent has not
had an ongoing relationship with the children for an extended period, time with the
children should begin with brief parenting time and a gradual transition to the Parenting
Plan in these guidelines.
E. Abduction Threats. Noncustodial parents who have threatened to abduct or hide the
children will have either no time with the children or only supervised time.
F. Breastfeeding Child. Parents must be sensitive to the special needs of breastfeeding
children. A child's basic sleep, feeding, and waking cycles should be maintained to limit
disruption in the child's routine. Forcibly changing these routines due to the upheaval of
parental disagreement is detrimental to the physical health and emotional well-being of the
child. On the other hand, it is important that the child be able to bond with both parents.
2.1 Children Under Age Five Generally. Newborns (birth to three months) and infants (three to
six months) have a great need for continuous contact with their primary caregiver, but also frequent
contact with both parents who provide a sense of security, nurturing, and predictability. Generally,
overnights for a very young child is not recommended unless the noncustodial parent is very
closely attached to the child and is able personally to provide primary care, the child is adaptable,
and the parents are cooperative. Older children are able to tolerate more and longer separations
from one parent or the other. The following guidelines for children under age five are designed to
take into account childhood developmental milestones. Since children mature at different rates,
these may need to be adjusted to fit a child's individual circumstances. These guidelines will not
apply in those instances where the parents are truly sharing equally all the caregiving
responsibilities for the children and the children are equally attached to both parents. In those
situations where the custodial parent has been the primary caregiver and the noncustodial parent
has maintained a continuous relationship with the children, but has not shared equally in child
caregiving, the following guidelines generally apply.
2.2 Newborns - Birth to Three Months. Three, two-hour custodial periods per week and one
weekend custodial period for six hours at the custodial parent's residence or another agreed
location. No overnights, except in circumstances described in 1.16 F(a) and (b) (noncustodial
parent caring for infant in accord with previous arrangements). Breastfeeding must be
accommodated, but the parents must cooperate in working out alternatives. See Paragraph 1.16 F
(breastfeeding).
2.3 Infants - Three to Six Months. Alternative Parenting Plans: (1) Three, three-hour custodial
periods per week, with one weekend day for six hours. Breast feeding must be accommodated. Or
(2) Three, three-hour custodial periods per week, with one overnight on a weekend for no longer
than a twelve-hour period, if the child is not breastfeeding and the noncustodial parent is capable
of personally providing primary care. See exceptions in Paragraph 1.16 F(a) and (b).
2.4 Babies - Six to Twelve Months. Alternative Parenting Plans: (1) Three custodial periods per
week of up to four hours each with one weekend day for six hours; or (2) Three custodial periods
per week of up to four hours each with one weekend day for six hours, but with one overnight not
to exceed twelve hours, if the child is not breastfeeding, and the noncustodial parent is capable of
providing personal primary care; or (3) Child spends time in alternate homes, but spends
significantly more time in one parent's home and no more than one to two overnights spaced
regularly throughout the week at the other parent's home, if the child is not breastfeeding. As to
arrangements (1), (2), and (3), see exceptions in Paragraph 1.16 F(a) and (b). Arrangement (3)
should be considered only for mature, adaptable children and cooperative parents.
2.5 Toddlers - Twelve to Thirty-six Months. Alternative Parenting Plans: (1) Three custodial periods per week of up to eight hours each on a predictable schedule; or (2) Three custodial periods
per week of up to eight hours each on a predictable schedule in addition to one overnight per week;
or (3) Child spends time in alternate homes, but with significantly more time in one parent's home
with one or two overnights spaced regularly throughout the week. Arrangement (3) requires an
adaptable child and cooperative parents.
2.6 Preschoolers - Three to Five Years. Alternative Parenting Plans: (1) One overnight custodial
period and one midweek custodial period with the child returning to the custodial parent's home
at least one hour before bedtime; or (2) Two or three nights at one home, spaced throughout the
week, the remaining time at the other parent's home. Arrangement (2) requires an adaptable child
and cooperative parents. In addition, a vacation of no longer than two weeks with the noncustodial
parent.
2.7 Children in Day Care. In families where a child has been in day care before the parental
separation, the child may be able to tolerate more time with the noncustodial parent earlier because
the child is more accustomed to separations from both parents. The noncustodial parent of a child
under age five should not during his/her time place the child with a babysitter or day care provider.
If the noncustodial parent cannot be with the child personally, the child should be returned to the
custodial parent. Allowing the child to visit with relatives for short periods of time may be
appropriate, if the relatives are not merely serving as babysitters. While a child is in day care, the
noncustodial parent may remove the child to have parenting time, provided that suitable prior
arrangements are made with both the custodial parent and the day care provider. This parenting
time must also not jeopardize the provision of the day care by that provider. The noncustodial
parent must be available to provide direct care and at least one day's notice is given to the custodial
parent. The parent removing the child is either to take the child to the other parent at the regular
pick up time, or see that the child is returned to day care prior to the pick up time. Parental
responsibility for day care costs will remain the same.
2.8 Holidays and Summer. For toddlers and preschool-age children, when the parents celebrate
the holiday in the same or a nearby community, the parents will alternate Christmas Eve and
Christmas Day each year so that the children spend equal time with each parent during this holiday
period. Other major holidays should also be divided between the parents. With children ages three
to five, a vacation of up to two weeks of uninterrupted time in the summer upon thirty days
advance written notice (by mail, email, or text message) is reasonable. Parents are encouraged to
coordinate vacation plans.
3. NONCUSTODIAL PARENTING TIME FOR CHILDREN OVER AGE FIVE WHEN
THERE IS SOLE CUSTODY OR PRIMARY PHYSICAL CUSTODY AND THE
PARENTS RESIDE NO MORE THAN 200 MILES APART.
3.1 Weekends. Parenting time will consist of alternate weekends from Friday at 5:30 p.m. to
Sunday at 7:00 p.m., or an equivalent period of time if the noncustodial parent is unavailable on
weekends and the children do not miss school. The starting and ending times may change to fit the
parents' schedules. In addition, if time and distance allow, the noncustodial parent may spend time
on a regular schedule with the children once or twice per week for two or three hours, or have one
midweek overnight time. In most cases, it is a positive experience for the children to have the
noncustodial parent involved in taking the children to and from school, and it is recommended that
the noncustodial parent extend the alternating weekends by picking up the children from school
on Friday and taking the children to school on Monday. All transportation for the midweek
custodial periods is the responsibility of the parent exercising them.
3.2 Mother's Day - Father's Day. The children shall be with their mother each Mother's Day and
with their father each Father's Day from 9:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Conflicts between these special
days and regular parenting time will be resolved under Paragraph 1.9.
3.3 Summer Vacation. The children will be with each parent for one-half of the school summer vacation. At the option of the noncustodial parent, the time may be consecutive or it may be split
into two or more blocks of time. If the children go to summer school and it is impossible for the
noncustodial parent to schedule this time other than during summer school, the noncustodial parent
may elect to take the time when the children are in summer school and transport the children to the
summer school sessions at the children's school or an equivalent summer school session in the
noncustodial parent's community.
3.4 Winter (Christmas) Vacation. The children will spend with each parent one-half of the
school winter vacation, a period that begins the evening the children are released from school and
continues to the evening of the day before the children will return to school. If the parents cannot
agree on the division of this period, the noncustodial parent will have the first half in
even-numbered years. Holidays, such as Christmas, are extremely important times of shared
enjoyment, family tradition, and meaning. Families living in the same or nearby communities must
work out ways for the children to spend part of each important holiday at both homes. If the
parents are unable to work out a shared arrangement for the Christmas/New Year holiday and they
celebrate the holidays in the same or a nearby community, in those years when Christmas does not
fall in a parent's week, the children will be with the other parent from 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. on
Christmas Day.
3.5 Holiday Weekends. Parents will alternate the following holiday weekends: Martin Luther
King, Jr. Day; President's Day; Easter; the 4th of July; Native Americans' Day; and Thanksgiving.
Thanksgiving will begin on Wednesday evening and end on Sunday evening; Easter weekend will
begin on Thursday evening and end on Sunday evening; Martin Luther King Jr. Day, President's
Day, and Native Americans' Day weekends will begin on the preceding Friday evening and end
on Monday evening; the 4th of July will begin the evening of July 3 at 5:00 p.m. and end the
morning of July 5 at 10:00 a.m. Unless otherwise specified, holiday weekends begin at 5:30 p.m.
and end at 7:00 p.m. on the designated days. The noncustodial parent will have Memorial Day
weekend and the custodial parent will have Labor Day weekend.
3.6 Children's Birthdays. As with holidays, a child's birthday will be alternated annually between
the parents. If a child's birthday falls on a weekend, it will be celebrated with the noncustodial
parent from 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. (or so much of the period as the noncustodial parent elects to
use). In some instances, the parents may agree to share the child's birthday, with each parent
spending a few hours with the child.
3.7 Parent's Birthdays. The children will spend the day with the parent on the parent's birthday,
unless it interferes with the other parent's scheduled time during a vacation or a major holiday. If
a parent's birthday falls on a holiday, that parent may elect to exercise parenting time on another
day during that month, upon sufficient advance notice to the other parent.
3.8 Conflicts Between Regular and Holiday Weekends. When there is a conflict between a
holiday weekend and the regularly scheduled weekend time with the parent, the holiday takes
precedence. Unless mutually agreed, there will be no makeup parenting time in conflicts between
holiday weekend and the regularly scheduled weekend time.
3.9 Parenting Time Before and During Summer Periods. The custodial parent will have the
weekend before the beginning and the weekend after the end of the noncustodial parent's summer
period, regardless of whose weekend it may be. Weekend time "missed" during the summer period
will not be "made up." During the noncustodial parent's extended summer time with the children
of more than three consecutive weeks, it will be the noncustodial parent's duty to arrange for a
mutually convenient 48-hour continuous period of time for the custodial parent to spend with the
children, unless impractical because of distance.
3.10 Notice of Canceled Time With the Children. Whenever possible, the noncustodial parent will give a minimum of three days notice of intent not to exercise all or part of the scheduled time with the children. When such notice is not reasonably possible, the maximum notice permitted by the circumstances, and the explanation, will be provided to the other parent. Custodial parents will
give the same type of notice when events beyond their control make the cancellation or
modification of the scheduled time with the noncustodial parent necessary. If the custodial parent
cancels or modifies the noncustodial parent's time with the children because the children have a
scheduling conflict, the noncustodial parent will be given the opportunity to take the children to
the scheduled event or appointment.
3.11 Pick Up and Return of Children. When the parents live in the same community, the
responsibility for picking up and returning the children will be shared. Usually the parent who
receives the children will handle the transportation. The person picking up or returning the children
has an obligation to be punctual, to arrive at the agreed-upon time, not substantially earlier or later.
Repeated, unjustified violations of this provision may subject the offender to court sanctions.
3.12 Additional Time With the Noncustodial Parent. The children's time with the noncustodial
parent should be liberal and flexible. For many parents, these guidelines should be considered only
a minimum direction for interaction with the children. These guidelines are not meant to foreclose
the parents from agreeing to modify the Parenting Plan as they find reasonable and in the best
interests of their children at any given time.
4. NONCUSTODIAL PARENTING TIME WITH CHILDREN OVER AGE FIVE WHEN
PARENTS RESIDE MORE THAN 200 MILES APART.
4.1 Summer and Holidays. This parenting time will consist of all but three weeks of the school
summer vacation period. It is recommended that the time start one week after school is out and end
two weeks before school begins so that the child will be well prepared to recommence school. In
addition, where distance and finances permit, on an alternating basis, the Thanksgiving break,
school winter (Christmas) break, and spring break will be with the noncustodial parent.
4.2 Priority of Summer Time With Noncustodial Parent. Summer time with the noncustodial
parent takes precedence over summer activities (such as sports) when the noncustodial parent's
time cannot be reasonably scheduled around such events. Even so, the conscientious noncustodial
parent will often be able to enroll the child in a similar activity in the noncustodial parent's
community.
4.3 Notice. At least sixty (60) days written notice (by mail, email, or text message) must be given
by the noncustodial parent of the date for commencing extended summer parenting time with the
children so that the most efficient means of transportation may be obtained and the parents and the
children may arrange their schedules. Failure to give the precise number of days notice does not
entitle the custodial parent the right to deny the noncustodial parent parenting time with the
children.
4.4 Additional Time with the Noncustodial Parent. Where distance and finances permit,
additional parenting time for the noncustodial parent, such as holiday weekends or special events,
is encouraged. When the noncustodial parent is in the area where the children reside, or the
children are in the area where the noncustodial parent resides, liberal time with the children must
be allowed and because the noncustodial parent does not get weekly time with the children, the
children can miss some school to spend time with the noncustodial parent, so long as it does not
substantially impair the children's scholastic progress.
5. Shared Parenting Plan. South Dakota law allows parents to agree in writing to a detailed
Shared Parenting Plan, which provides that the children will reside no less than one hundred eighty
nights per calendar year in each parent's home, and that the parents will share the duties and
responsibilities of parenting the children and the expenses of the children in proportion to their
incomes. Such Shared Parenting Plan must be incorporated into the custody order. SDCL
25-7-6.27. A Shared Parenting Plan requires adaptable children and cooperative parents.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this rule shall become effective April 18, 2012.