Committee: Appropriations Subcommittee # 1
Representative J. E. Putnam, Chair
Senator William J. Johnson, Vice Chair
Senator Robert M. Benson
Representative William F. Cerny
Representative Michael Derby
Senator Robert Drake
Representative Robert N. Duxbury
Representative Kenneth G. McNenny
Representative Donald E. Munson
Senator Paul Symens was excused.
LRC staff present during the meeting included David Becker, Senior Fiscal Analyst; and Arlene
Krueger, Senior Session Secretary. A list of guests attending the meeting and all documents
presented are filed with the original minutes. The committee received Document S, LRC briefing.
Mr. Mark Lausang, SDHDA director of finance, pointed out that the majority of the budget changes pertain to the Governor's Transitional Housing Program (THP). The two-pronged goal is to provide the elderly with lower maintenance, energy efficient homes, thereby freeing their larger old homes for younger families at an affordable price. Criteria are age 62 or older, or an adult household member who has certifiably been diagnosed with a disability, in towns of 5,000 population or less. Springfield State Prison inmates build the houses and are reimbursed $196 per house, which equates
to $2 per day per prisoner. The Department of Corrections pays for the house and normal costs. Representative Duxbury inquired whether South Dakota suppliers get contracts for the supplies, to which Ms. Baum replied a balance between best price, most efficient delivery, and working with in- state suppliers is sought, but contracts are awarded both in and out of state. The eight additional FTEs include seasonal and full-time employees: two truck drivers, four escort drivers who are on
call, a project supervisor, and three construction supervisors with expertise in HVAC and plumbing,
general construction, and electrical areas. One truck driver has been kept busy full time negotiating
with private contractors and following up. Two new semi trucks and federal surplus property escort
vehicles have been purchased by SDHDA to move houses to the appropriate locations. Because
SDHDA is not a state agency, it carries its own insurance. Contracts are in place with private
moving companies to set the houses on foundations. Ms. Baum noted that they expect to move
houses to Mission and Rapid City this week. The one in Rapid City will be a show house, and plans
are to market Rapid City during the stock show. The absolute capacity of around 200 homes a year
is budgeted. Ms. Baum said 55 are sold and 32 purchase orders are pending. Of those sold, 54 are
the 768 square foot handicap adaptable homes; only one of the 672 square foot homes has been sold.
Marketing is done through Councils of Government, and SDHDA has an 800 number. Senator
Drake asked whether they have considered building any larger houses. Ms. Baum replied they are
again working a balance. Since they do not want to compete with the building industry, she doubts
any larger homes will be built for this program. These homes are about the same size as two
bedroom apartments.
Mr. David Volk, Secretary, Department of Commerce (DOC), stated that, excluding fleet and
movement to midpoint, there is essentially no change in the Division of the Secretariat budget.
Since the state is no longer penalized for lack of a motorcycle helmet law, a substantial block of
federal funds has been directed to the Department of Transportation for highway construction, rather
than defaulting to the Division of Public Safety. Mr. Volk said the Governor directed a change of
focus for the Division, from public information and program delivery to more concrete services such
as the Child Safety Seat Program (the number distributed has increased from 300 to almost 4,000),
Driving Under the Influence (DUI) enforcement, overtime, and ambulance emergency equipment.
Ms. Jeannette Schipper, head of the division of the Secretariat, interjected that one director and one
administrative assistant are shared by two divisions: Public Safety and Human Relations. In the past
Public Safety had six FTEs, now there are three. Representative Duxbury observed that last year
they wanted to carry $1.4 million into the next fiscal year; Ms. Schipper responded that they never
received the $3.3 million which they expected, so the budget authority is being reduced. She stated
they now expect close to $900,000, which, with carry over, is close to $1 million. She advised that
the Global Positioning System money went to the Department of Transportation.
Representative Putnam asked what was being done with the $3.00 assessment for motorcycle
licenses and was told that last year 390 cyclists were trained by the South Dakota Safety Council.
The answer to Representative McNenny's question about Law Enforcement Training was that there
was a redirection of priorities, and, at the request of the Governor, this is being reconsidered.
The Gaming budget is informational with no significant change, and Securities is essentially a status
quo budget. Representative Duxbury recalled last year's discussion about the investigation of
brokerage firm compliance, and Ms. Deb Bollinger, Division Director, responded that the inspection
program has been running a little over a year. Many senior citizens' questions are being addressed
with good results. Secretary Volk added that the mere presence of inspectors in the communities
is a deterrent. He said federal legislation with regard to licensing changes the department's role.
Ms. Bollinger commented that the state investment advising firms with less than $25 million in
managed assets must register with the state, which retains enforcement jurisdiction and the power
to fine agents or firms who violate securities laws. The department works closely with the Attorney
General's office, she added. In this fast-growing field, she said only about 10 South Dakota
investment firms are not linked to a major house. She handed out a breakdown of Division of
Securities Performance Indicators and Revenues ( Document U) and advised that next year the line
Blue Chip Exemptions will be called Notification Filing Fees. SB 82 will be revenue neutral
but registration fees will be blue chip exempt, she advised.
Mr. Volk commented that SB 81 establishing an insurance fraud unit would utilize three vacant
FTEs, including a special assistant or assistant attorney general for prosecution. Division of
Insurance Director Darla Lyon amplified that SB 81 has an assessment of up to $250 per company
(about 1500 companies) to be placed into a fund to operate the fraud unit. She said 36 states have
insurance fraud units because the Insurance Division is essentially a reporting unit. In Nebraska's
first year, the 199 cases referred were resolved for $13 million. Ms. Schipper noted this unit was
conceptual when the budget was drawn up, and there isn't an offset shown in the requested budget.
Representative Munson inferred that if SB 81 does not pass, two FTEs can be cut and the budget
accordingly reduced. Cases forwarded to the division by states attorneys are now sent back to them.
Secretary Volk said a unit is needed to focus directly on this problem for investors, for prosecution,
and for public information. Ms. Lyon noted that the Attorney General is supportive of this bill.
Representatives Putnam and Derby questioned the role of private investigators. Ms. Lyon replied
that insurance companies will continue to hire private investigators to conduct investigations to
determine whether they will pay the claims; the private sector will see no change. The insurance
industry is very supportive because it costs them a lot of money to pay fraudulent claims, and they
expect to save billions of dollars, according to Ms. Lyon. The Chair requested a bill brief on SB 81.
Representative Duxbury asked about the effects of the severe winter storms and livestock losses.
Mr. Duncan responded that bankers will have to be flexible and imaginative in working with
ranchers. It will require more work for everybody, but our banks are strong, competently managed,
and well capitalized.
Secretary Volk stated that the biggest change in Commercial Inspection and Licensing is how
trucks will be purchased for the Weights and Measures section: replacement costs will be reflected
in the mileage rate, so will appear in the budget. The new program for issuing drivers' licenses from
county court houses allowed a cut back in FTE; Secretary Volk stated it was costing up to $180 to
issue one $8 driver's license when they had to send their teams out. People in the county court house
are trained to give the tests, and a temporary license is issued. Not a citizen or a county has
complained. Ms. Pam Kusler noted that when examiners traveled to Highmore, 157 licenses were
issued in a year; the number now is approximately 350. She said this represents additional revenue
for counties, in the fees they retain and in money saved by the Department of Commerce which
flows to them in the road and bridge fund. City issuance programs have also been instituted in Faith
and Lemmon. Once volume reaches a certain point, however, this is not cost effective.
In response to Representative Duxbury's questions about fire inspections in the schools, Fire
Marshal Dan Carlson advised this function has been transferred to the new Department of
Inspection. Two years ago the currency rate was 22%; six months after the change it was 42%, and
is now nearly 100%. According to statute inspections are required every other year. A report is
filed, the inspector conducts an exit interview with the school, which submits a plan for corrective
action to be reviewed by the Fire Marshal's office, which offers help or alternatives.
The Highway Patrol has an authorized strength of 239; however Superintendent Gene Abdallah advised that the uniformed force is 14 down from the 157 authorized because of problems in recruiting and four officers on sick leave. At full strength, not counting commanders, there are not over 16 troopers on the highways at any one time, he noted. Speeding isn't the trooper's only job.
The Governor has prioritized DUIs and drug interdiction, and troopers must also be in court and
work on accident reconstruction. The nine January recruits won't be on the street until almost
August. There is a reduction of one clerical FTE. The Superintendent also stated that from
December 1 to last week 14 cars were taken out of commission, two totaled. DUI arrests have
increased 22% for the year, but speeding arrests and fines are down, which he does not attribute to
the increased speed limit. Chair Putnam requested a clarification on whether the Department of
Transportation (DOT) will lose federal funds for noncompliance with speed limits.
The Chair asked about activity on the reservations. Officers do not patrol at all on the Pine Ridge
or Rosebud Reservations, according to Major Tom Dravland, and are basically off the new Yankton
Reservation. Through verbal agreements, they can patrol on or through the Standing Rock and
Cheyenne Reservations, but they generally turn people over to tribal authorities. Troopers are
allowed on the Lower Brule and Crow Creek Reservations, but don't patrol except by invitation.
Addressing the recent problem of highway closings, Major Dravland explained that three district
commanders discuss the situation with regional DOT engineers, then Major Dravland and DOT's
Director of Operations make the decision. He then notifies the Associated Press, the gates are shut,
and a final sweep is done if possible to make sure people aren't stranded. Representative Duxbury
asked how the changes in State Radio have worked out. Superintendent Abdallah responded that
State Radio is antiquated and needs extensive updating. Different entities have different frequencies,
and one trooper in Lemmon has communication with nobody.
Superintendent Abdallah informed the committee that the canine unit is doing an outstanding job
in the detection of drugs. Property which is seized is turned over to the Attorney General's office
and is usually disposed of by auction, with the proceeds going to the Attorney General's drug fund.
United States Attorneys can prosecute large or interstate cases on a federal level, in which case the
federal government takes 20% of seized assets, and 80% is distributed to local law enforcement
according to their participation in the case. Seizures at the Sturgis Rally last year enabled the
Highway Patrol to buy a house from the Housing Authority to replace a dilapidated trailer. Major
Dravland noted that the $250,000 in the Attorney General's fund can be shared back with local law
enforcement.
Discussion ensued on safety in construction zones; Major Dravland said they try to coordinate with
DOT and the sites they consider most hazardous. Surveillance is best accomplished with aircraft.
Superintendent Abdallah interjected that DOT is considering the purchase of speed bumps.
Ms. Schipper pointed out that fleet consolidation has resulted in a decrease in capital assets and has
affected operating expenses. She confirmed that DOC no longer owns the Highway Patrol vehicles.
As previously noted, the Division of Human Rights administrator and clerical support are shared with Highway Safety. Ms. Schipper said they do not have a budget from the Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission yet this year, but there were some cut backs. The backlog in this
department has been eliminated, and Secretary Volk said efforts could be redirected to the field away
from Washington, which has a backlog of 100,000 cases.
Representative Cerny asked that information be provided about the Plumbing Commission.
A motion for adjournment was made by Representative McNenny, seconded by Senator Benson, and
carried on a voice vote. The Chair adjourned the meeting at 11:00 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Arlene G. Krueger
Committee Secretary