State of South Dakota
|
EIGHTY-SEVENTH SESSION
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY, 2012
|
273T0785
|
HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION NO. 1012
|
Introduced by: Representatives Olson (Betty), Brunner, Cronin, Dennert, Fargen, Greenfield,
Hansen (Jon), Hubbel, Jensen, Jones, Kirkeby, Kloucek, Kopp, Liss, Miller,
Russell, Schaefer, Schrempp, Steele, Stricherz, Van Gerpen, Vanneman,
Verchio, and Wink and Senators Maher, Begalka, Bradford, Brown, Frerichs,
Juhnke, Rampelberg, Rhoden, and Sutton
|
A CONCURRENT RESOLUTION, Directing the Department of Game, Fish and Parks to
return a mountain lion carcass or pelt to a certain Harding County resident and to reconsider
its policy with respect to possession of mountain lion carcasses and pelts.
WHEREAS, based on state law recognizing wildlife as the property of the public and
allowing licensed hunters to possess wildlife animals taken according to the terms of the license,
the Department of Game, Fish and Parks will confiscate the carcasses and pelts of mountain
lions that are taken outside the terms of a hunting license, regardless of any extenuating
circumstances in individual situations; and
WHEREAS, SDCL 41-6-29.1 authorizes a person, licensed or unlicensed, to kill a mountain
lion if reasonably necessary to protect the life of any person or if the mountain lion poses an
imminent threat to the person's livestock or pets; and
WHEREAS, on November 19, 2011, a rancher from Harding County who possessed a
license to hunt mountain lions was feeding his sheep when his cattle dogs disappeared. After
he finished feeding, he searched for the dogs and found them barking at a mountain lion in a
tree. He immediately took his .22 magnum rifle, which he keeps with him at all times, and shot
the lion. He then called Game, Fish and Parks to report his kill as instructed on the license. The
game warden came to the ranch and confiscated the mountain lion, even though the rancher had
a valid license to hunt mountain lions. The rancher not only shot the mountain lion with a too
small caliber rifle, but he also told the warden about his dogs finding the mountain lion, and
state law prohibits the use of dogs in hunting mountain lions. The rancher has purchased a
license to hunt mountain lions for several years because he wanted to keep the lion if he ever
shot one; and
WHEREAS, in this case, the immediate circumstances of the situation made it impossible,
or extremely imprudent and potentially threatening to life or property, to follow all of the
requirements of the mountain lion hunting license with respect to caliber of the weapon and the
presence of dogs. The person in question held a valid mountain lion hunting license, acted in
a prudent manner to address what could have been an emergency situation, and reported his
actions promptly and honestly to the Department of Game, Fish and Parks; and
WHEREAS, the interpretation of state statute resulting in the confiscation of the mountain
lion in this instance is unfair and falls outside the spirit of the statute:
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the House of Representatives of the Eighty-seventh Legislature of the State of South Dakota, the Senate concurring therein, that the South
Dakota Legislature requests the Department of Game, Fish and Parks, in the case described in
this resolution, to return the mountain lion carcass or pelt to the licensed hunter who shot the
mountain lion; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Legislature urges the Department of Game, Fish
and Parks to reconsider its policies relating to the confiscation of mountain lions taken by
licensed hunters in situations in which circumstances require immediate action to protect the
safety of persons and property.