P - Present
E - Excused
A - Absent
Roll Call
P Putnam, Vice-Chair
P Madden
P Kleven
P Greenfield
E Apa
P Duxbury
P Dennert
P Drake, Chair
P Cradduck
OTHERS PRESENT: See Original Minutes
The meeting was called to order by Chair Richter
(Meeting jointly with House)
Mark Zickrick, Principal Fiscal Analyst, staffed the meeting.
Representative Richter explained that Avera McKennan and Rapid City Regional hospitals had been
invited to meet with the committee and discuss their involvement in the upcoming changes in the
School of Medicine. He invited Dr. Robert Talley to provide background information.
School of Medicine
Dr. Robert Talley, Dean, School of Medicine explained that due to the implosion of University
Physicians, the School of Medicine is facing a $1.2 million decrease in its budget and is
implementing a community-based management program to replace University Physicians. Under
this system, faculty will be paid based on actual time spent teaching students. These changes have
to be put in place this next year and will require a very high quality assessment program, as medical
students have 8,000 contacts per year and every contact needs to be documented.
In response to questions from Representative Richter, Dean Talley said the University Physicians
debt is a manageable one for which the state is not responsible. Representative Richter commented
that the state is responsible for a possible one-time cost of $508,486, to pay annual and sick leave
for faculty leaving the school.
Avera McKennan
Fred W. Slunecka, Regional President, Avera McKennan, responded to questions from the
committee.
Representative Richter questioned Avera McKennan's future involvement with the School of
Medicine. Mr. Slunecka said that the future of the School of Medicine is very important to Avera
as the hospital has a long history with the medical school. He said that the medical school's
psychiatric residency program is located at Avera McKennan and that the hospital provides
approximately $700,000 annually subsidizing this program, and this does not include the federal
funding that passes through the hospital because of the psychiatric program.
Mr. Slunecka said that he would like to see an expansion of the internal medicine program. He said
that Avera presently sponsors two full-time internal medicine residencies for the medical school and
wants the number of residencies to three in the future.
In response to Representative Richter, Mr. Slunecka said that the $700,000 subsidy Avera provides
the School of Medicine will increase to $1 million this year and he anticipates a $300,000 annual
subsidy for the expanded internal medicine program. He said that Avera will be watching to see how
the new medical school management program develops. He said the hospital will be asked to
provide medical support for the medical school at a rate that doesn't reflect the hospital's true costs.
In response to a question from Representative Adelstein, Mr. Slunecka said that Avera McKennan
supports one-half of the School of Medicine's clinical residencies that are in Sioux Falls. He said
the division of the residencies between Sioux Valley and Avera McKennan has evolved over time.
Also in response to Representative Adelstein's questions, Mr. Slunecka said that there are no faculty
members on the Avera McKennan board of directors nor have Avera McKennan officials been
invited to participant on the School of Medicine's board. Mr. Slunecka indicated that it is essential
for everyone to get behind the School of Medicine and he is opposed to any actions that will decrease
the school's political base of support. He couldn't speak as to how much money Avena would have
paid for the use of the medical school's name.
In response to Representative Richter, Mr. Slunecka indicated that Avera should be a part in assisting
with the School of Medicine's accreditation needs.
Rapid City Regional
Adil Ameer, CEO, Rapid City Regional Hospital, appeared before the committee.
Mr. Ameer spoke of three elements in the relationship between Rapid City Regional and the School
of Medicine as being: a clinical for the 3rd and 4th year students; the family practice residency
program; and the assistance of University Physicians has provided in recruitment efforts for
physicians in specialty medicines.
In response to Representative Adelstein, Mr. Ameer said that Rapid City Regional had not been
invited to be on the University Physicians or School of Medicines boards and likewise these entities
had not sought to be on the Rapid City Regional's boards. Mr. Ameer said he would not speculate
nor comment on this situation. He said that the hospital is quite concerned with the implosion of the
University Physicians.
There was a discussion between Representative Adelstein and Mr. Ameer concerning the expanded
possibility of hospitals providing medical care to the reservations. Senator Putnam suggested that
this could be discussed in the Tribal Relations Committee.
Senator Putnam questioned whether Rapid City Regional had invited medical school or University
Physicians to be on the hospital's board. Mr. Ameer indicated that there had not been discussions.
In response to Senator Putnam, Mr. Ameer indicated that once analyzed, Rapid City Regional and
the School of Medicine could come up with a mutually acceptable arrangement.
University of South Dakota
James W. Abbott, President, The University of South Dakota, spoke to the committee. He said that
the programs previously discussed by Avena McKennan and Rapid City Regional had little to do
with the $20 million required to operate the medical school, of which $9 million comes from the
state. He said the School of Medicine needs funds for and that the School of Medicine accepts
money from hospitals because the school can't operate without this support.
Representative Richter commented that the appropriations committee has initiated discussions with
the hospitals, that there is a new medical school mission and role, that the state needs to continue to
help facilitate meetings,that the medical school is important to the state.
President Abbott said that the $300,000 needed for the medical assessment component needs to be
totally independent from the hospitals. He again emphasized that for the School of Medicine to be
independent from the hospitals, it needs to be funded independently.
President Abbott requested that there be no summer studies on the medical school this summer as
the school needs to gear up for accreditation; however, next year would be a good time for a study.
MOTION:
ADJOURN
Moved by: Klaudt
Second by: Madden
Action: Prevailed by voice vote.
Rena K. Ortbahn
____________________________
Committee SecretaryBob Drake, Chair
../02191000.SAPPage 1