P - Present
E - Excused
A - Absent
Roll Call
P Putnam, Vice-Chair
P Madden
P Kleven
P Greenfield
P Apa
P Duxbury
E Dennert
P Drake, Chair
P Cradduck
OTHERS PRESENT: See Original Minutes
The meeting was called to order by Co-Chair Drake
The meeting was held jointly with the House Committee
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES
Mr. Reed Holwegner, LRC, provided budget information for the committee (Document #1).
Mr. James W. Ellenbecker, Secretary, Department of Social Services, presented a budget overview
for FY2003 assisted by Mike Vogel, Deputy Secretary, Department of Social Services and Darla
Blaseg, Director of Management Services in Social Services.
The Department of Social Services aids people to maintain the basic necessities of life. This
includes protecting people from physical and mental harm when they cannot protect themselves the
helping people attain their highest level of independence.
The FY2003 Governor's total recommended budget is $554,277,504. The funding sources include:
the general funds is $164,273,577 which is an increase of $12,215,188, the federal funds is
$375,694,740 which a decrease of $1,351,521, and other funds is $14,309,187 which is a decrease
of $6,950,710. The FY2003 recommended budget for FTE is 954.5 which is an increase of 12.0
from the FY2002 operating budget.
Mr. Ellenbecker said that there are three things that affect the budget. They are the following:
inflation, relationship with the federal government concerning Medicaid funds, and growth in
services to clients.
Senator Apa asked if the positions were filled for the FY2002 appropriated FTEs of 942.5. Ms.
Blaseg responded that all positions are full with the exception of 1.7 which are advertised. .
Representative Pummel asked about the turnover rate in the department. Mr. Ellenbecker said that
it is above 20 percent for caseworkers and 35 percent for social workers.
Representative Burg asked if the department was serving fewer nursing home residents, could DOC
adults be placed in nursing homes. Mr. Ellenbecker said that individuals would need to be released
from the Department of Corrections, and that his department would be glad to work with the DOC.
Senator Madden asked about the increase in nursing home residents due to the aging baby boomers.
Mr. Ellenbecker said that this group will probably utilize assisted living care. Nursing home care
would be the last resort for health care.
Senator Putnam asked for clarification of the 2.1 percent and 2.9 percent inflation rates in the
Governor's recommended budget. Mr. Ellenbecker said for routine administrative functions, the
inflation rate is 2.1 percent for those programs that deal with health care.
Senator Kleven asked about the responsibilities of the FTEs. Mr. Ellenbecker said there is an
increase of 20 additional FTEs for the increase in medical assistant caseloads.
SECRETARIAT
The mission of the secretariat is to provide effective delivery of social services in South Dakota by
efficiently managing all offices, programs, and activities of the department in cooperation with
federal, state, and local government agencies through program coordination and budgetary review;
and, to provide the following administrative support services essential to the effective management
of the department's programs: legal, statistical analysis, budgetary and financial management,
provider reimbursement and audits, and purchasing.
The total Governor's recommended budget is $8,984,771. Funding sources include: the general
fund( $3,589,560), federal funds( $5,331,797), and other funds( $63,414). The total FY2003 FTEs
is 57.0.
Senator Drake asked why the agency had requested $6,000,000 for computer services. Mr.
Ellenbecker replied that the department needs to be in compliance with federal rules dealing with
the privacy of recipients' health information. The federal rules, promulgated by the US Department
of Health and Human Services, are authorized by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability
(HIPAA) Act. He is hopeful that with the compliance deadline moved from April,2003 to October
,2003, the agency will be able to cover the costs of planning within the recommended budget. The
agency would then request the necessary funds for FY2004.
Representative Clark asked what the $6,000,000 would be for. Mr. Ellenbecker said that it would
pay for software and the change to a new system providing new uniform forms.
Senator Apa asked why the department was making the change in computer services. Mr.
Ellenbecker responded that the consumers wanted a more uniform system that insured privacy, and
Congress is mandating compliance for all health care related entities.
The Governor recommends $5,966,898 for computer services. This includes $2,242,725 from the
general fund, $3,668,888 from federal funds, and $55,285 from other funds. This is a decrease of
$834,781 (12.3 percent) from FY2002.
PROGRAM MANAGEMENT
The mission of program management is to direct the provision of Social Services through overall
supervision of program development, policies and procedures, and budgets; to direct and manage
the Medicaid and Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) eligibility programs; to conduct
quality control and quality assurance measures in the TANF, food Stamps, and Medicaid Programs;
to provide management information to Department of Social Services' programs based on conclusive
field investigations; to direct and manage the education programs for children in the custody of the
Department of Social Services; and, to conduct administrative hearings.
Program Management supervises and coordinates policy development and direction in the major
program divisions of the department. The total Governor's recommended budget is $8,873,137. The
funding sources include: the general fund ( $7,232,997), and federal funds ( $1,640,140). The total
FY2003 FTEs is 37.5.
Auxiliary Placement. The Governor recommends $6,755,241 which includes $6,303,363 from the
general fund and $451,878 from federal funds. This is an increase of $1,583,092 (30.6 percent) from
the FY 2002 budget. The program pays for the tuition and related service costs for children under
the care of the state or other approved entities as required by SDCL 13-28-39. The recommendation
includes $1,433,462 ($1,391,887 from the general fund) for additional children, from 409 to 466 in
FY2003. The recommendation also includes $149,630 ($137,854 from the general fund) for an
inflationary increase of 2.9 percent.
Representative Clark asked for information about the education costs of the department. Mr.
Ellenbecker said that his department pays the costs incurred at Turning Point, some academies, and
some local school programs.
Senator Drake asked if the students qualify for the average daily membership (ADM). Agency
personnel responded that the children qualify for education funding, and the department deducts that
amount from any auxillary placement funds. The Department of Education and Cultural Affairs
pays for the education first.
Senator Putnam asked if any child was eligible for double dipping. The department agency
personnel said, Yes. The department agency said that it is concerned about double dipping. Social
Services is working with the Department of Education and Cultural Affairs. The money is compared
to see who is paying for what. Every child is cross-referenced. Senator Putnam asked if the
department was always one year behind in payments.
Senator Putnam asked about the costs for each of the 85 individuals that are in the custody of DOC.
Ms. Randall said that the costs differ for each child. Senator Putnam asked for more information
about the 85 students transferred from Plankinton, and how much it costs for each.
Senator Drake asked for additional information on the 85 Plankinton students in local school
districts.
Representative Burg asked how the department arrived at the total of 85 Plankinton students. He
understood there were 58 students at that training school.
Representative Richter informed the committee that some students were in Plankinton and others
were in various correctional facilities to bring the total to 85 students.
Senator Drake asked if the department would clarify in writing the number of students the
department has absorbed from the closing of the state training school.
Senator Richter informed the committee that this is a rolling number and that the committee needs
to get more information about the location of students.
The mission of economic assistance is to provide financial, medical, food, and energy assistance to
eligible South Dakotans to enable them to achieve and maintain a reasonable standard of living
compatible with decency and health; and, to administer grant programs for victim assistance and
poverty assistance in South Dakota in accordance with applicable federal and state laws.
ECONOMIC ASSISTANCE
The Economic Assistance division provides money, medical, food, and energy assistance to eligible
people. The division also administers the Victim Assistance and Poverty Assistance Grant programs.
The Governor's total recommended budget is $33,005,486. The funding sources include:THE
general fund is ($8,466,672), federal funds ( $24,240,619), and other funds ( $298,195). The
FY2003 total recommended FTE is 31.0.
The TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) Program helps needy families and children
by emphasizing a work first philosophy. Welfare reform provisions in the Personal Responsibility
and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 gave states the flexibility needed to design
programs that would help able-bodied parents and their families become self-sufficient. This law
also specified federally mandated participation rates and time limited benefits
The Governor recommends $11,016,766 for TANF Grants which includes $5,030,600 from the
general fund and $5,986,166 from federal funds. This is a decrease of $1,000,911 (8.3 percent) from
FY2002. This is due to a projected growth in caseloads that did not materialize. In FY2001 there
were 2,729 cases. The department estimates 2,775 cases in FY2002 and FY2003, an increase of 46
cases. The monthly average payment is expected to be $324.90.
South Dakota's TANF caseload has continued to decline from a caseload of 5,319 cases in
December,1996. In December, 2001, there were 2,987 families receiving assistance grants, of which
1,293 cases contained an able-bodied parent who must participate in work program activities. Most
of this reduction has come from this portion of the caseload. That portion of the caseload that is
child only cases (cases headed by a non-parent caretaker relative or disabled parent) has not
changed significantly.
At the same time, South Dakota has successfully met federally required work participation rates.
In FY1997, the federal participation rate requirement started at 25 percent and increased by 5 percent
each of the first three years with participation rates of 44.8 percent, 39.2 percent, 45.5 percent
respectively. While the participation rates for FY2000 and FY2001 have yet to be released, the
department anticipates that South Dakota will once again exceed the federal requirements.
South Dakota families with parent head-of-households may receive cash assistance for their families
for no more than 60 months. The first month that counted toward this lifetime limit was
December,1996. Because of the success in moving families from the welfare roles through a strong
work first philosophy and the added focus on strengthening the family nucleus by helping recipients
pursue a high school education, parenting classes, and referrals to partnering agencies, the
department expects that less than 20 families will reach their lifetime limits in the next few months.
Most of these families have severe health issues that prevent them from entering the workforce. As
a result, some qualifying families may be eligible to receive extended benefits beyond the 60-month
limit based on hardship criteria that has been established by rule.
Senator Putnam asked if South Dakota received incentives for the TANF program. Mr. Mike Vogel
told the committee that there were high incentive bonuses given a few years ago.
Senator Apa asked for a written breakdown of field staff for the TANF program. This would be the
number of caseworkers and caseloads.
For the seventh year in a row South Dakota's Food Stamp Program achieved the highest case
payment accuracy rate in the nation: 98.82 percent. In recognition of that achievement, the United
State Department of Agriculture awarded the department with a $731,693 bonus payment. In total,
food stamp staff has brought in over $9,000,000 in bonus payments over the past 17 years. This is
a record that no other state has come close to matching.
Senator Apa asked if there were additional staff needed for the debit card program used for the food
stamp program. Mr. Ellenbecker said that no extra help was needed, but some are trained.
Electronic Benefits Transfer_Electronic payments: The department continues to expand the use of
computer technology to increase administrative efficiency and are working to replace benefit checks
and warrants with electronic payments. In April, 2001, DSS Adult Services and Aging (ASA)
respite care and homemaker providers began receiving direct deposit. Electronic payments are more
efficient, more accountable and less expensive than paper based systems. They offer recipients and
service providers an added degree of convenience and security. The department processes
approximately 12,5000 direct deposit payments per month to custodial parents, low income heating
assistance fuel suppliers, child care assistance providers , assisted living providers, ASA respite care
and homemaker providers and optional Supplemental Security Income recipients. This is an increase
of almost 3,000 more direct deposit payments per month than what was processed last year. The
department will add additional ASA providers to direct deposit in 2002 and will be exploring other
DSS programs that may benefit from direct deposit.
Representative Clark expressed a concern with the number of low income families who do not have
computers in their homes to take advantage of the electronic benefits transfer. Mr. Ellenbecker said
that was a concern, but computers are available in public libraries.
Heating Assistance- applications for the Low Income Energy Assistance Program (LIEAP) are now
available on the Internet for applicants to print, complete and mail. To achieve greater efficiency,
these transactions will be completed electronically. Approximately 17,000 households apply for
heating assistance annually. The program will allow the electronic billing of claims for payment to
energy suppliers. A portion of energy assistance funds will be designated to purchase heat meters
and demand control devices for the LIEAP clients. This will allow electricity to be purchased at a
lower rate and reduce dependency on the program.
The Governor recommends $7,589,680 from federal funds for the Low Income Energy Assistance
Program (LIEAP). This is an increase of $2,330,000 (40.2 percent) from FY2002. LIEAP helps pay
heating costs by making payments directly to the energy supplier. It can also pay for emergency
heating system repairs. The program is designed to supplement payments made by people who
would otherwise be unable to pay the full cost of heating their home. The agency estimates 14,800
households will be served in FY2003.
Senator Madden asked how the energy budget was affected by a warm winter season when energy
assistance is not needed. Mr. Ellenbecker responded that the funds would be carried over to the next
fiscal year.
Representative Clark asked for an explanation on the use and cost of heat meters and demand control
devices. Mr. Ellenbecker said that his department would get the information to the committee.
Senator Greenfield asked for the amount in the budget for energy assistance for the current year. Ms.
Blaseg said there is $7,600,000 for energy assistance.
Weatherization Assistance Program - replacement of water heaters is being included as an approved
weatherization measure because energy used to heat water is exceeded only by the energy used for
space heating in most homes. Air conditioners will be installed for individuals with certain medical
conditions.
Senator Kleven asked if those people who apply for weatherization assistance are living in
apartments. Mr. Vogel said that people who rent may receive assistance within the guidelines. He
would accurately describe the guidelines for the committee in writing.
The committee then heard the agency's report of the FY2003 and FY2004 Community Services
Block Grant (CSBG). Mr. Mike Vogel presented a summary (Document #3).
The purpose of the Community Services Block Grant is to provide assistance to states and local
communities working through a network of community action agencies and other neighborhood-
based organizations to (1) reduce of poverty, (2) the revitalize low-income communities, and (3)
empower low-income families and individuals in rural and urban areas to become fully self-
sufficient, particularly families who are attempting to transition off a state program carried out under
Part A of Title IV of the Social Security Act.
Expected funding for the FY2003 Community Services Block Grant are being determined by HHS,
Office of Community Services. South Dakota will receive approximately $2,824,693. The funding
for FY2004 is expected to be the same as FY2003. The amount available to the Department of
Social Services may change slightly due to the amount of CSBG funding that is directly granted1 to
Indian tribes. For FY2003, the state will allocate $2,824,693 in CSBG funds. For budgeting
purposes, the FY2004 amount is projected to be $2,825,000.
According to the Community Services Block Grant Act, 90 percent of the state's annual
CSBG allotment must be passed through to eligible entities. Eligible entities are further defined
to be community action agencies or agencies that have a tripartite board consisting of low-income
persons democratically elected, public officials, and private sector persons. The state is authorized
a minimum of five percent of the allotment, or $55,000, whichever is greater, for administrative
purposes with the remaining funds allotted for discretionary projects or programs determined by the
Governor. Based on the expected funding level, the state should have approximately $141,235
available each year for administrative costs and discretionary programs. The four designated
community action agencies that receive CSBG funding are private, non-profit agencies. They
include: Inter-Lakes Community Action Agency in Madison, Northeast South Dakota Community
Action Program in Sisseton, Rural Office of Community Services in Lake Andes, and Western South
Dakota Community Action Program in Rapid City.
Representative Richter asked how the department determines the distribution for each community
action agency program. Mr. Vogel said it is based upon the estimated number of low income people
in the area served by the community action agency.
Representative Klaudt said that the Community Services Block Grant looks like a duplication of
services. Volunteer organizations could provide school supplies for needy families.
Ms. Linda Edel, Western South Dakota Community Action Program in Rapid City, informed the
committee about various aspects of her community program. She said that programs are based on
local needs of individuals and families. The program staff is limited. Food commodity distribution
and medical equipment lending, air conditioner distribution, hygiene product distribution,
weatherization assistance, and school supplies distribution are program components.
The committee hearing for the Community Services Block Grant ended.
The Joint Appropriations Committee then continued the budget hearing for the Department of Social
Services.
Senator Adelstein asked for additional information about the additional money recommended for
the department because of the closing of the State Training School in Plankinton.
Representative Richter said that he would work with the Department of Human Services and the
Department of Corrections for a one page summary of the numbers generated from the closing of
the State Training School.
Senator Adelstein asked if there are different TANF programs for members of the tribal
communities. Mr. Ellenbecker said that the program addresses all South Dakota citizens. There are
2,917 TANF cases which includes reservation and non-reservation counties.
Representative Klaudt asked if there is a cost share with the reservations for TANF programs. Mr.
Ellenbecker said that if tribes wanted to administer their own programs, they would only receive
federal funds. TANF is under review by some of the tribes.
Representative Richter wanted information on money sent to reservations, dollar matches, and the
tribal contacts on the reservations. Mr. Ellenbecker said that a lot of money is spent on reservations
from the general funds. The tribal personnel varies so the contact pool is not consistent.
Representative Richter discussed inviting tribal representatives to speak to the committee about the
reservation's child care services. Mr. Ellenbecker said that the tribal chairperson is the appropriate
contact.
Representative Clarence Kooistra presented information in support of the TANF program. He
encouraged the committee to consider the reserves to be spent for the South Dakota families at the
poverty level.
Reverend Phil Lint, from the Blunt, Harrold, Highmore United Methodist Churches, presented
information in support of the TANF program. He said that there are many working people who are
struggling financially. There are many children who come alone and with families to the weekly free
banquet.
Representative Adelstein asked if Reverend Lint and the community work with their community
action program. He encouraged him to start such a program.
Representative Klaudt asked if the banquet was privately funded. Reverend Lint said that it is
volunteer based. They use the Southeast Community Center and local churches and civic
organizations make donations.
Ms. Cathy Brechtelsbauer, Bread for the World, Sioux Falls presented information on the TANF
grant allocation (Documents #4 and #5). She asked the grant inflationary adjustments for TANF
payments be increased to average $9.00 per month for each qualifying family.
Senator Drake asked about what programs a family of three could qualify for according to TANF.
Ms. Brechtelsbauer said they would get full benefits for food stamps. Senator Drake stated that the
family would receive energy assistance and food stamps. The TANF payments are their only cash.
Representative Clark asked about the total cost of inflation for the TANF program. Ms.
Brechtelsbauer said the percentage increase is needed to adjust the poverty line and to get federal
money that belongs to the children.
Ms. Jeanne Koster, South Dakota Peace and Justice Center, asked for federal funds to be given to
children in South Dakota who are living in poverty.
Ms. Susan Randall, South Dakota Coalition for Children, testified that children deserve a cost of
living increase.
Mr. Ellenbecker responded to the testimonies and said that there has never been a policy to grant
inflationary increase for TANF. South Dakota watches surrounding states as to their increases for
TANF. He said that the department has a healthy reserve.
Representative Lange asked about the department's policy to not increase TANF inflationary costs.
Mr. Ellenbecker told the committee that the department is in compliance according to the
surrounding states. Representative Lange said that we should do better for our South Dakota
children.
Representative Klaudt asked about the possibility of increasing wages and not putting the program
benefits in jeopardy. He asked if the earnings amount could be increased.
Representative Adelstein asked about the 2,775 TANF recipients per month. Ms. Blaseg told the
committee that the state receives $22,000,000 from the federal government. The funds pay for cash
assistance, work programs, and child care.
Representative Clark asked about the five year limit for people to use TANF funds. Mr. Ellenbecker
said that the Native Americans on the reservations are exempt from the five year limit.
Representative Adelstein asked about the inception of the TANF funds. Mr. Ellenbecker said that
the use of program funds has grown every year.
Representative Richter informed the committee of TANF history. Five or six years ago, the
Legislature developed a policy which allowed to build a reserve of TANF funds. That reserve now
equals approximately $17,000,000.
MOTION:
ADJOURN
Moved by: Madden
Second by: Klaudt
Action: Prevailed by voice vote.
Carol Carney
____________________________
Committee SecretaryBob Drake, Chair
../01290800.SAPPage 1