76th Legislative Session _ 2001

Committee: House Agriculture and Natural Resources
Thursday, February 01, 2001

                                            P - Present
                                            E - Excused
                                            A - Absent

Roll Call
P    Bradford
P    Fryslie
P    Hanson (Gary)
P    Hargens
P    Holbeck
P    Jensen
P    Kloucek
P    Pitts
P    Rhoden
P    Sigdestad
P    Van Gerpen
P    Lintz, Vice-Chair
P    Duenwald, Chair

OTHERS PRESENT: See Original Minutes

The meeting was called to order by Vice Chairman Jim Lintz.

MOTION:     TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF TUESDAY, JANUARY 30, 2001.

Moved by:    Hargens
Second by:    Van Gerpen
Action:    Prevailed by voice vote.

         HB 1170: prohibit the tampering with anhydrous ammonia and to provide a penalty for a violation thereof.

Presented By:    Representative Mike Jaspers, prime sponsor
Proponents:    Kathy Zander, executive director, SD Agri-Business Association
        Brenda Forman, lobbyist, SD Association of Agricultural Coops


        Mike Leidholt, Hughes County Sheriff and President of the SD Sheriffs Ass'n.
        Charles McGuigan, Attorney General's Office

MOTION:     DO PASS HB 1170

Moved by:    Van Gerpen
Second by:    Hanson (Gary)
Action:    Prevailed by roll call vote.(12-0-1-0)

Voting Yes:    Bradford, Fryslie, Hanson (Gary), Hargens, Holbeck, Jensen, Kloucek, Pitts, Rhoden, Sigdestad, Van Gerpen, Lintz

Excused:    Duenwald

MOTION:     PLACE HB 1170 ON CONSENT

Moved by:    Hargens
Second by:    Jensen
Action:    Prevailed by voice vote.

         HB 1136: provide for the protection of certain agricultural contractors.

Testimony was heard on HB 1136 at a previous meeting.

Presented By:    Representative Frank Kloucek, prime sponsor
Proponents:    Bob Mack, self, Watertown
        Doug Sombke, self and vice president of the SD Farmers Union
Opponents:    Mark Barnett, SD Attorney General
        Tom Leckey, Secretary of State's Office
        Larry Gabriel, Secretary of Agriculture
        Tom Adam, lobbyist, SD Bankers Association
        Carl Anderson, lobbyist, SD Grain and Feed Association
Comments by: Neil Fulton, Farm Credit Services of America
        Roxanne Giedd, Attorney General's Office

MOTION:     DEFER HB 1136 TO THE 41ST LEGISLATIVE DAY

Moved by:    Duenwald
Second by:    Fryslie
Action:    Was not acted on.

MOTION:     SUBSTITUTE MOTION AMEND HB 1136



1136ta
     On the printed bill, delete everything after the enacting clause and insert:

"      Section 1. Terms used in this Act mean:

             (1)    "Active contractor," a person who owns a commodity produced by a contract producer according to a production contract;

             (2)    "Agricultural contract," a marketing or a production contract;

             (3)    "Capital investment," an investment in a structure, such as a building or manure storage structure, or machinery or equipment with a useful life exceeding one year and associated with the production of a commodity;
             (4)    "Commodity," livestock, raw milk, or a crop;

             (5)    "Contract crop field," farmland on which a crop is produced according to a production contract;

             (6)    "Contract livestock facility," an animal feeding operation that produces livestock or raw milk according to a production contract. The term includes a confinement feeding operation, an open feedlot, land on which crops or other vegetation is grown and used to graze or feed livestock, or land used to feed livestock for slaughter;

             (7)    "Contract operation," a contract livestock facility or a contract crop field;

             (8)    "Contract producer," a producer who holds a legal interest in a contract operation and who produces a commodity under a production contract;

             (9)    "Contractor," a person who is an active contractor or a passive contractor;

             (10)    "Crop," a plant used for food, animal feed, fiber, oil, pharmaceuticals, netriceuticals, or seed, including alfalfa, barley, buckwheat, corn, flax, forage, millet, oats, popcorn, rye, sorghum, soybeans, sunflowers, tobacco, wheat, and grasses used for forage or silage;

             (11)    "Livestock," beef cattle, dairy cattle, poultry, sheep, or swine;

             (12)    "Marketing contract," a written agreement between a processor and a producer for the purchase of commodities grown or raised by the producer in this state. A marketing contract is executed when it is signed or orally agreed to by each party or by a person authorized to act on the party's behalf;

             (13)    "Passive contractor," a person who furnishes management services to a contract producer and who does not own a commodity that is produced by the contract producer according to a production contract;

             (14)    "Processor," a person engaged in the business of manufacturing goods from commodities, including by slaughtering or processing livestock, processing raw milk or crops. The term does not include custom exempt plants as defined in § 39-5-6(4);

             (15)    "Produce," to provide feed or services relating to the care and feeding of livestock, including milking dairy cattle and storing raw milk. The term also means planting, raising, harvesting, and storing a crop, including preparing the soil for planting and nurturing the crop by the application of fertilizers, soil conditioners, or pesticides;

             (16)    "Producer," a person who produces a commodity. The term does not include a commercial fertilizer or pesticide applicator, feed supplier, veterinarian, grain warehouse, or custom harvester if acting in such capacity;

             (17)    "Production contract," a written agreement that provides for the production of a commodity or the provision of management services relating to the production of a commodity by a contract producer. A production contract is executed if it is signed by each party to the contract or by a person authorized to act on the party's behalf. Production contracts include all contracts where the production contract is executed by an active contractor and a contract producer, the production contract is executed by an active contractor and a passive contractor for the provision of management services to the contract producer, or the production contract is executed by a passive contractor and a contract producer where the passive contractor provides management services to the contract producer.

     Section 2. Execution of an agricultural contract imposes an obligation of good faith, as defined in § 57A-1-201(19), on all parties with respect to the contract's performance and enforcement.

     Section 3. Agricultural contracts executed or amended after the effective date of this Act shall be accompanied by a clear written disclosure statement setting forth the nature of the material risks, described below, faced by the producer upon entry into the contract. The disclosure statement shall meet the readability requirements of section 5 of this Act and shall disclose the following:

             (1)    In the case of production contracts, the producer's right to review as provided in section 6 of this Act;

             (2)    Contract duration;

             (3)    Contract termination;

             (4)    Renegotiation standards;

             (5)    Responsibility for environmental damage;

             (6)    Factors to be used in determining payment; and

             (7)    Responsibility for obtaining and complying with local, state, federal permits.

     Section 4. An agricultural contract executed or amended after the effective date of this Act shall contain a cover sheet as the first page or pages of text. The cover sheet shall contain:

             (1)    A brief statement that the document is a legal contract between the parties;

             (2)    The following statement: "READ YOUR CONTRACT CAREFULLY. This cover sheet provides only a brief summary of your contract. This is not the contract and only the terms of the actual contract are legally binding. The contract itself sets forth, in detail, the rights and obligations of both you and the contractor or processor. IT IS THEREFORE IMPORTANT THAT YOU READ YOUR CONTRACT CAREFULLY";

             (3)    The disclosure statement required by section 3 of this Act; and

             (4)    An index of the major provisions of the contract and the pages on which they are found, including all of the following:

             (a)    The names of all parties to the contract.;

             (b)    The definition sections of the contract;

             (c)    The provisions governing termination, cancellation, renewal, and amendment of the contract by either party;

             (d)    The duties or obligations of each party; and

             (e)    Any provisions subject to change in the contract.

     Section 5. An agricultural contract executed or amended after the effective date of this Act shall be in legible type with a typeface of at least ten-point modern type, appropriately divided and captioned by its various sections, and written in clear and coherent language using simple sentence structure, clear definitions, and words and grammar understandable by a person of average intelligence, education, and experience within the industry. A contract shall avoid esoteric legal terms and minimize references to other sections or provisions. The following terms may be used in an agricultural contract:

             (1)    Legally required terms, including particular words, phrases, provisions, or forms of agreement specifically required, recommended, or endorsed by a state or federal statute, rule, or regulation;

             (2)    Customarily used terms, including technical terms used to describe the services or property that are the subject of the contract, if the terms are customarily used by producers in the ordinary course of business in connection with the services or property being described.

     Section 6. A contract producer may cancel a production contract by mailing a written cancellation notice to the contractor within three business days after the contract is executed, or by the cancellation deadline if specified in the contract, whichever is later. The contract producer's right to cancel, the method by which the contract producer may cancel, and the deadline for canceling the production contract shall be clearly disclosed in every production contract.

     Section 7. Any provision of an agricultural contract executed or amended after the effective date of this Act that imposes confidentiality on information other than trade secrets contained in the agricultural contract, is void. Such a provision is void whether it is express or implied; oral or written; required or conditional; or contained in the agricultural contract, another agricultural contract, or in a related document, policy, or agreement. Other provisions of an agricultural contract or a related document, policy, or agreement that can be given effect without the voided provision are not affected. This section does not require a party to an agricultural contract to divulge information about the contract to another person.

     Section 8. A contract producer has a lien for the amount owed by an active contractor pursuant to the terms of the production contract.

     Section 9. If the production contract is for livestock, the lien established pursuant to section 8 of this Act applies as follows:

             (1)    If the livestock is not sold or slaughtered by the contractor, the lien is on the livestock;

             (2)    If the livestock is sold by the contractor, the lien is on sale proceeds;

             (3)    If the livestock is slaughtered by the contractor, the lien is on any property of the contractor that may be subject to a security interest as provided in §  57A-9-102.

     Section 10. If the production contract is for raw milk, the lien established pursuant to section 8 of this Act applies as follows:

             (1)    If the raw milk is not sold or processed by the contractor, the lien is on the raw milk;

             (2)    If the raw milk is sold by the contractor, the lien is on sale proceeds;

             (3)    If the raw milk is processed by the contractor, the lien is on any property of the contractor that may be subject to a security interest as provided in §  57A-9-102.

     Section 11. A lien on livestock or raw milk under this Act is created at the time the livestock first arrives at the contract facility and continues for one year after the livestock leaves the contract facility.

     Section 12. If the production contract is for crops, the lien established pursuant to section 8 of this Act applies as follows:

             (1)    If the crop is not sold or processed by the contractor, the lien is on the crop;

             (2)    If the crop is sold by the contractor, the lien is on cash sale proceeds.;

             (3)    If the crop is processed by the contractor, the lien is on any property of the contractor that may be subject to a security interest as provided in §  57A-9-102.;

             (4)    A lien on a crop is created at the time the crop is first planted and continues for one year after the crop, or grain from the crop, is no longer under the custody or control of the contract producer.

     Section 13. In order to preserve a lien created pursuant to section 8 if this Act, a contract producer shall file a lien statement with the secretary of state on a form prescribed by the secretary of state. A lien statement covering the production of livestock or raw milk, must be filed within forty-five days after the livestock first arrives at the contract livestock facility. A lien statement covering crops must be filed within forty-five days after the crop is first planted. The secretary of state may charge a fee in accordance with the provisions of § 57A-9-525 for filing the statement. The secretary of state may adopt rules pursuant to chapter 1-26 for the filing and release of lien statements, fees, and electronic filings.

     Section 14. The lien statement filed pursuant to section 13 of this Act shall include:

             (1)    The name and address of the contract producer;

             (2)    The name of the active contractor whose commodity is produced pursuant to the production contract; and

             (3)    The location of the contract operation, by county and township.

     Section 15. A lien statement filed pursuant to section 13 of this Act shall be released by the

contract producer upon payment of the amount owed pursuant to the production contract. A release shall be filed with the secretary of state, on a form prescribed by the secretary, within thirty days after payment.

     Section 16. A contract producer may foreclose a lien created under section 8 of this Act in the manner provided for the foreclosure of secured transactions in chapter 57A-9.

     Section 17. A lien created pursuant to this Act has priority over all other liens and encumbrances if filed within forty-five days after the livestock first arrives at the contract facility or within forty- five days after the crop is first planted.

     Section 18. Sections 19 to 22, inclusive, of this Act only apply to a production contract executed by a contract producer and a contractor, if the contract producer must make capital investments of one hundred thousand dollars or more. The amount of the capital investment is determined by aggregating the investment requirements provided in all production contracts in which the contract producer and the contractor are parties. The value of the capital investments is the total dollar amount spent by the contract producer in satisfying the investment requirements.

     Section 19. Except as provided in section 21 of this Act, a contractor may not terminate or cancel a production contract until providing the contract producer written notice at least ninety days before the effective date of the termination or cancellation, and the contract producer has been reimbursed for damages incurred due to the termination or cancellation. Damages shall be based on the value of the remaining useful life of the structures, machinery, or equipment involved.

     Section 20. Except as provided in section 21 of this Act, a contractor may not terminate or cancel a production contract that has been materially breached by a contract producer until the contractor has provided written notice of termination or cancellation at least forty-five days before its effective date, which contains the alleged causes constituting the breach, and the contract producer has failed to remedy each breach within thirty days following receipt of the notice. An effort by a contract producer to remedy an alleged breach may not be construed as an admission of a breach in a civil cause of action.

     Section 21. A contractor may terminate or cancel a production contract without notice or remedy as required in sections 19 and 20 of this Act if the basis for the termination or cancellation is voluntary abandonment of the contractual relationship by the contract producer by a failure of a contract producer to perform the obligations of a production contract, or the conviction of a contract producer of fraud or theft committed against the contractor.

     Section 22. If a contractor terminates or cancels a production contract other than provided in sections 19 to 21, inclusive, of this Act, the contractor shall pay the contract producer the value of the remaining useful life of the structures, machinery, or equipment involved.


     Section 23. For purposes of this Act, the term, contract input, means a commodity or an organic or synthetic substance or compound used to produce a commodity, including livestock or plants, agricultural seeds, semen or eggs for breeding livestock, and fertilizer or pesticide.

     Section 24. For purposes of this Act, the term, producer right, means one of the following legal rights and protections:

             (1)    The right of a producer to join or belong to, or to refrain from joining or belonging to, an association of producers;

             (2)    The right of a producer to enter into a membership agreement or marketing contract with an association of producers, a processor, or another producer, and the right of the producer to exercise contractual rights under such a membership agreement or marketing contract;

             (3)    The right of a producer to lawfully provide statements or information, including statements or information to the United States Secretary of Agriculture or to a law enforcement agency, regarding alleged improper actions or violations of law by a contractor or processor. This right does not include the right to make libelous or slanderous statements;

             (4)    The right of a contract producer to file, terminate, or enforce a lien as provided by sections 8 to 17, inclusive, of this Act;

             (5)    The right of a contract producer to have production contracts reviewed by financial professionals, by legal counsel, and as provided by section 6 of this Act;

             (6)    The right of a producer to disclose the terms of agricultural contracts as provided by section 7 of this Act; and

             (7)    The right of a producer to exercise other protections afforded by this Act or other laws, rules, or regulations.

     Section 25. No contractor or processor may knowingly engage, or permit any employee or agent to engage, in any of the following actions to coerce, intimidate, disadvantage, retaliate against, or discriminate against any producer because the producer exercises, or attempts to exercise, any producer right. Such actions include:

             (1)    The execution, termination, extension, or renewal of an agricultural contract;

             (2)    Treatment of a producer that includes placing discriminatory or preferential terms in an agricultural contract or interpreting terms of an existing agricultural contract in a discriminatory or preferential manner. For purposes of this section, terms includes the

price paid for a commodity, the quality or the quantity of a commodity demanded, financing, or investment requirements;

             (3)    The grant or denial of a reward or imposition of a penalty, including financial rewards or penalties such as loans, bonuses, or inducements;

             (4)    The alteration of the quality, quantity, or delivery times of contract inputs provided to a producer;

     Section 26. No contractor or processor may knowingly do, or permit any employee or agent to do, any of the following:

             (1)    Provide false information to the producer, including that related to the character, financial condition, or management practices of a producer with whom the producer associates, or an association of producers, or an agricultural organization with which the producer is affiliated, or producer rights provide by this Act or other provisions of law;

             (2)    Refuse to provide to a contract producer statistical information and data used to determine the compensation paid under a production contract, including feed conversion rates, feed analyses, or origination and breeder history;

             (3)    Refuse to allow a contract producer or a designated representative to observe at the time of weighing, the weights and measures used to determine the contract producer's compensation under a production contract;

             (4)    Use a contract producer's performance, also known as "tournament compensation" to determine the compensation due another contract producer under a production contract, or to use that performance as the basis of the termination, cancellation, or renewal of a production contract;

             (5)    Require a contract producer to make new or additional capital investments in connection with, or to retain, continue, or renew, a production contract. It is not be a violation of this section if such new or additional capital investments are partially paid for by the contractor, or are offset by other compensation or modifications to the original contract agreed to in writing as consideration for the new capital investment;

             (6)    Execute an agricultural contract in violation of the disclosure of risks and readability requirements of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act;

             (7)    Execute an agricultural contract that includes a confidentiality provision in violation of section 7 of this Act;

             (8)    Execute an agricultural contract without a mediation provision as required under section 29 of this Act;

             (9)    Execute an agricultural contract that includes a waiver of any producer right or any obligation of a contractor or processor established under this Act;

             (10)    Execute an agricultural contract requiring the application of the law of another state.

     Section 27. Any provision of an agricultural contract that waives a producer right or a contractor or processor obligation established by this Act is void and unenforceable. No such provision affects other provisions of an agricultural contract, related document, policy, or agreement, that can be given effect without the voided provision.

     Section 28. Any condition, stipulation, or provision of an agricultural contract requiring the application of the law of another state is void and unenforceable.

     Section 29. An agricultural contract shall contain language providing for resolution of disputes by mediation.

     Section 30. A contractor or processor committing an unfair practice under sections 23 to 26, inclusive, of this Act is subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars per violation.

     Section 31. A producer who suffers damages because of a contractor's or processor's violation of this Act may obtain appropriate legal and equitable relief, including damages, pursuant to the rules of civil procedure. The court may award the prevailing producer reasonable attorney fees and other litigation expenses. A producer is not required to post a bond, prove the absence of an adequate remedy at law, or show the existence of special circumstances, to obtain temporary or permanent injunctive relief unless the court for good cause otherwise orders.

     Section 32. In addition to the remedies provided in this Act, a court reviewing an agricultural contract may change the terms of the contract or limit a provision to avoid an unfair result if the court finds:

             (1)    A material provision of the contract violates sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act;

             (2)    The violation caused the producer to be substantially confused about any of the rights, obligations, or remedies of the contract; and

             (3)    The violation has caused or is likely to cause financial detriment to the producer.

     If the court reforms or limits a provision of an agricultural contract, the court shall also make orders necessary to avoid unjust enrichment. Bringing a claim for relief under this section does not

entitle a producer to withhold performance of an otherwise valid contractual obligation. No relief may be granted under this section unless the claim is brought before the obligations of the contract have been fully performed.

     Section 33. In a proceeding in which civil penalties are claimed from a party for a violation of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act, it is a defense to the claim that the party made a good faith and reasonable effort to comply.

     Section 34. Notwithstanding section 31 of this Act, a party who has made a good faith and reasonable effort to comply may not be assessed attorney's fees for violations of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act.

     Section 35. Violation of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act is not a defense to a claim arising from a producer's breach of an agricultural contract. A producer may recover actual damages caused by a violation of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act only if the violation caused the producer to not understand the rights, obligations, or remedies of the contract.

     Section 36. A claim that an agricultural contract violates sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act must be raised within six years of the date the contract is executed by the producer.

     Section 37. In addition to using other appropriate remedies, the attorney general may enforce the provisions of this Act, through injunctive action to restrain a contractor or processor from engaging in conduct or practices in violation of this Act, or to require a contractor or processor to comply with a provision of this Act. To accomplish the objectives and to carry out the provisions of this Act, the attorney general issue a subpoena to any contractor or processor to obtain an agricultural contract. Any person failing to comply with such subpoena may be certified to circuit court, for enforcement by order. Noncompliance with a judicial order shall be treated the same as a contempt of the court.

     Section 38. The attorney general or state's attorney may also bring an action in circuit court for recovery of civil penalties provided in section 30 of this Act.

     Section 39. This Act does not apply to:

             (1)    Agricultural contracts based on a sharecropping arrangement or agreement;
             (2)    Agricultural contracts in which all parties executing the contract are producers;
             (3)    Any contract involving forward contracting of livestock or grain entered into with any packer, dairy, milk or milk products processor, public grain warehouse, grain dealer, or grain or livestock exchange or other commodity exchange ;
             (4)    Any contract involving a grain processing cooperative that is exempt under section 521 of the federal Internal Revenue Code as amended to January 1, 2001."

Moved by:    Kloucek


Second by:    Hargens
Action:    Was not acted on.

MOTION:     SUBSTITUTE MOTION TO TABLE AMENDMENT

Moved by:    Duenwald
Second by:    Rhoden
Action:    Prevailed by roll call vote.(9-4-0-0)

Voting Yes:    Fryslie, Hanson (Gary), Holbeck, Jensen, Pitts, Rhoden, Van Gerpen, Lintz, Duenwald

Voting No:    Bradford, Hargens, Kloucek, Sigdestad

MOTION:     SUBSTITUTE MOTION AMEND HB 1136

1136tb
     On the printed bill, delete everything after the enacting clause and insert:

"      Section 1. Terms used in this Act mean:

             (1)    "Active contractor," a person who owns a commodity produced by a contract producer according to a production contract;

             (2)    "Agricultural contract," a marketing or a production contract;

             (3)    "Capital investment," an investment in a structure, such as a building or manure storage structure, or machinery or equipment with a useful life exceeding one year and associated with the production of a commodity;
             (4)    "Commodity," livestock, raw milk, or a crop;

             (5)    "Contract crop field," farmland on which a crop is produced according to a production contract;

             (6)    "Contract livestock facility," an animal feeding operation that produces livestock or raw milk according to a production contract. The term includes a confinement feeding operation, an open feedlot, land on which crops or other vegetation is grown and used to graze or feed livestock, or land used to feed livestock for slaughter;

             (7)    "Contract operation," a contract livestock facility or a contract crop field;

             (8)    "Contract producer," a producer who holds a legal interest in a contract operation and who

produces a commodity under a production contract;

             (9)    "Contractor," a person who is an active contractor or a passive contractor;

             (10)    "Crop," a plant used for food, animal feed, fiber, oil, pharmaceuticals, netriceuticals, or seed, including alfalfa, barley, buckwheat, corn, flax, forage, millet, oats, popcorn, rye, sorghum, soybeans, sunflowers, tobacco, wheat, and grasses used for forage or silage;

             (11)    "Livestock," beef cattle, dairy cattle, poultry, sheep, or swine;

             (12)    "Marketing contract," a written agreement between a processor and a producer for the purchase of commodities grown or raised by the producer in this state. A marketing contract is executed when it is signed or orally agreed to by each party or by a person authorized to act on the party's behalf;

             (13)    "Passive contractor," a person who furnishes management services to a contract producer and who does not own a commodity that is produced by the contract producer according to a production contract;

             (14)    "Processor," a person engaged in the business of manufacturing goods from commodities, including by slaughtering or processing livestock, processing raw milk or crops. The term does not include custom exempt plants as defined in § 39-5-6(4);

             (15)    "Produce," to provide feed or services relating to the care and feeding of livestock, including milking dairy cattle and storing raw milk. The term also means planting, raising, harvesting, and storing a crop, including preparing the soil for planting and nurturing the crop by the application of fertilizers, soil conditioners, or pesticides;

             (16)    "Producer," a person who produces a commodity. The term does not include a commercial fertilizer or pesticide applicator, feed supplier, veterinarian, grain warehouse, or custom harvester if acting in such capacity;

             (17)    "Production contract," a written agreement that provides for the production of a commodity or the provision of management services relating to the production of a commodity by a contract producer. A production contract is executed if it is signed by each party to the contract or by a person authorized to act on the party's behalf. Production contracts include all contracts where the production contract is executed by an active contractor and a contract producer, the production contract is executed by an active contractor and a passive contractor for the provision of management services to the contract producer, or the production contract is executed by a passive contractor and a contract producer where the passive contractor provides management services to the contract producer.

     Section 2. Execution of an agricultural contract imposes an obligation of good faith, as defined in § 57A-1-201(19), on all parties with respect to the contract's performance and enforcement.

     Section 3. Agricultural contracts executed or amended after the effective date of this Act shall be accompanied by a clear written disclosure statement setting forth the nature of the material risks, described below, faced by the producer upon entry into the contract. The disclosure statement shall meet the readability requirements of section 5 of this Act and shall disclose the following:

             (1)    In the case of production contracts, the producer's right to review as provided in section 6 of this Act;

             (2)    Contract duration;

             (3)    Contract termination;

             (4)    Renegotiation standards;

             (5)    Responsibility for environmental damage;

             (6)    Factors to be used in determining payment; and

             (7)    Responsibility for obtaining and complying with local, state, federal permits.

     Section 4. An agricultural contract executed or amended after the effective date of this Act shall contain a cover sheet as the first page or pages of text. The cover sheet shall contain:

             (1)    A brief statement that the document is a legal contract between the parties;

             (2)    The following statement: "READ YOUR CONTRACT CAREFULLY. This cover sheet provides only a brief summary of your contract. This is not the contract and only the terms of the actual contract are legally binding. The contract itself sets forth, in detail, the rights and obligations of both you and the contractor or processor. IT IS THEREFORE IMPORTANT THAT YOU READ YOUR CONTRACT CAREFULLY";

             (3)    The disclosure statement required by section 3 of this Act; and

             (4)    An index of the major provisions of the contract and the pages on which they are found, including all of the following:

             (a)    The names of all parties to the contract.;

             (b)    The definition sections of the contract;

             (c)    The provisions governing termination, cancellation, renewal, and amendment of the contract by either party;

             (d)    The duties or obligations of each party; and

             (e)    Any provisions subject to change in the contract.

     Section 5. An agricultural contract executed or amended after the effective date of this Act shall be in legible type with a typeface of at least ten-point modern type, appropriately divided and captioned by its various sections, and written in clear and coherent language using simple sentence structure, clear definitions, and words and grammar understandable by a person of average intelligence, education, and experience within the industry. A contract shall avoid esoteric legal terms and minimize references to other sections or provisions. The following terms may be used in an agricultural contract:

             (1)    Legally required terms, including particular words, phrases, provisions, or forms of agreement specifically required, recommended, or endorsed by a state or federal statute, rule, or regulation;

             (2)    Customarily used terms, including technical terms used to describe the services or property that are the subject of the contract, if the terms are customarily used by producers in the ordinary course of business in connection with the services or property being described.

     Section 6. A contract producer may cancel a production contract by mailing a written cancellation notice to the contractor within three business days after the contract is executed, or by the cancellation deadline if specified in the contract, whichever is later. The contract producer's right to cancel, the method by which the contract producer may cancel, and the deadline for canceling the production contract shall be clearly disclosed in every production contract.

     Section 7. Any provision of an agricultural contract executed or amended after the effective date of this Act that imposes confidentiality on information other than trade secrets contained in the agricultural contract, is void. Such a provision is void whether it is express or implied; oral or written; required or conditional; or contained in the agricultural contract, another agricultural contract, or in a related document, policy, or agreement. Other provisions of an agricultural contract or a related document, policy, or agreement that can be given effect without the voided provision are not affected. This section does not require a party to an agricultural contract to divulge information about the contract to another person.

     Section 8. Sections 9 to 12, inclusive, of this Act only apply to a production contract executed by a contract producer and a contractor, if the contract producer must make capital investments of one hundred thousand dollars or more. The amount of the capital investment is determined by

aggregating the investment requirements provided in all production contracts in which the contract producer and the contractor are parties. The value of the capital investments is the total dollar amount spent by the contract producer in satisfying the investment requirements.

     Section 9. Except as provided in section 11 of this Act, a contractor may not terminate or cancel a production contract until providing the contract producer written notice at least ninety days before the effective date of the termination or cancellation, and the contract producer has been reimbursed for damages incurred due to the termination or cancellation. Damages shall be based on the value of the remaining useful life of the structures, machinery, or equipment involved.

     Section 10. Except as provided in section 11 of this Act, a contractor may not terminate or cancel a production contract that has been materially breached by a contract producer until the contractor has provided written notice of termination or cancellation at least forty-five days before its effective date, which contains the alleged causes constituting the breach, and the contract producer has failed to remedy each breach within thirty days following receipt of the notice. An effort by a contract producer to remedy an alleged breach may not be construed as an admission of a breach in a civil cause of action.

     Section 11. A contractor may terminate or cancel a production contract without notice or remedy as required in sections 9 and 10 of this Act if the basis for the termination or cancellation is voluntary abandonment of the contractual relationship by the contract producer by a failure of a contract producer to perform the obligations of a production contract, or the conviction of a contract producer of fraud or theft committed against the contractor.

     Section 12. If a contractor terminates or cancels a production contract other than provided in sections 9 to 11, inclusive, of this Act, the contractor shall pay the contract producer the value of the remaining useful life of the structures, machinery, or equipment involved.

     Section 13. For purposes of this Act, the term, contract input, means a commodity or an organic or synthetic substance or compound used to produce a commodity, including livestock or plants, agricultural seeds, semen or eggs for breeding livestock, and fertilizer or pesticide.

     Section 14. For purposes of this Act, the term, producer right, means one of the following legal rights and protections:

             (1)    The right of a producer to join or belong to, or to refrain from joining or belonging to, an association of producers;

             (2)    The right of a producer to enter into a membership agreement or marketing contract with an association of producers, a processor, or another producer, and the right of the producer to exercise contractual rights under such a membership agreement or marketing contract;

             (3)    The right of a producer to lawfully provide statements or information, including statements or information to the United States Secretary of Agriculture or to a law enforcement agency, regarding alleged improper actions or violations of law by a contractor or processor. This right does not include the right to make libelous or slanderous statements;

             (4)    The right of a contract producer to have production contracts reviewed by financial professionals, by legal counsel, and as provided by section 6 of this Act;

             (5)    The right of a producer to disclose the terms of agricultural contracts as provided by section 7 of this Act; and

             (6)    The right of a producer to exercise other protections afforded by this Act or other laws, rules, or regulations.

     Section 15. No contractor or processor may knowingly engage or permit any employee or agent to engage in any of the following actions to coerce, intimidate, disadvantage, retaliate against, or discriminate against any producer because the producer exercises, or attempts to exercise, any producer right. Such actions include:

             (1)    The execution, termination, extension, or renewal of an agricultural contract;

             (2)    Treatment of a producer that includes placing discriminatory or preferential terms in an agricultural contract or interpreting terms of an existing agricultural contract in a discriminatory or preferential manner. For purposes of this section, terms includes the price paid for a commodity, the quality or the quantity of a commodity demanded, financing, or investment requirements;

             (3)    The grant or denial of a reward or imposition of a penalty, including financial rewards or penalties such as loans, bonuses, or inducements;

             (4)    The alteration of the quality, quantity, or delivery times of contract inputs provided to a producer;

     Section 16. No contractor or processor may knowingly do, or permit any employee or agent to do, any of the following:

             (1)    Provide false information to the producer, including that related to the character, financial condition, or management practices of a producer with whom the producer associates, or an association of producers, or an agricultural organization with which the producer is affiliated, or producer rights provide by this Act or other provisions of law;

             (2)    Refuse to provide to a contract producer statistical information and data used to determine the compensation paid under a production contract, including feed conversion rates, feed analyses, or origination and breeder history;

             (3)    Refuse to allow a contract producer or a designated representative to observe at the time of weighing, the weights and measures used to determine the contract producer's compensation under a production contract;

             (4)    Use a contract producer's performance, also known as "tournament compensation" to determine the compensation due another contract producer under a production contract, or to use that performance as the basis of the termination, cancellation, or renewal of a production contract;

             (5)    Require a contract producer to make new or additional capital investments in connection with, or to retain, continue, or renew, a production contract. It is not be a violation of this section if such new or additional capital investments are partially paid for by the contractor, or are offset by other compensation or modifications to the original contract agreed to in writing as consideration for the new capital investment;

             (6)    Execute an agricultural contract in violation of the disclosure of risks and readability requirements of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act;

             (7)    Execute an agricultural contract that includes a confidentiality provision in violation of section 7 of this Act;

             (8)    Execute an agricultural contract without a mediation provision as required under section 19 of this Act;

             (9)    Execute an agricultural contract that includes a waiver of any producer right or any obligation of a contractor or processor established under this Act;

             (10)    Execute an agricultural contract requiring the application of the law of another state.

     Section 17. Any provision of an agricultural contract that waives a producer right or a contractor or processor obligation established by this Act is void and unenforceable. No such provision affects other provisions of an agricultural contract, related document, policy, or agreement, that can be given effect without the voided provision.

     Section 18. Any condition, stipulation, or provision of an agricultural contract requiring the application of the law of another state is void and unenforceable.

     Section 19. An agricultural contract shall contain language providing for resolution of disputes

by mediation.

     Section 20. A contractor or processor committing an unfair practice under sections 13 to 16, inclusive, of this Act is subject to a civil penalty of up to ten thousand dollars per violation.

     Section 21. A producer who suffers damages because of a contractor's or processor's violation of this Act may obtain appropriate legal and equitable relief, including damages, pursuant to the rules of civil procedure. The court may award the prevailing producer reasonable attorney fees and other litigation expenses. A producer is not required to post a bond, prove the absence of an adequate remedy at law, or show the existence of special circumstances, to obtain temporary or permanent injunctive relief unless the court for good cause otherwise orders.

     Section 22. In addition to the remedies provided in this Act, a court reviewing an agricultural contract may change the terms of the contract or limit a provision to avoid an unfair result if the court finds:

             (1)    A material provision of the contract violates sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act;

             (2)    The violation caused the producer to be substantially confused about any of the rights, obligations, or remedies of the contract; and

             (3)    The violation has caused or is likely to cause financial detriment to the producer.

     If the court reforms or limits a provision of an agricultural contract, the court shall also make orders necessary to avoid unjust enrichment. Bringing a claim for relief under this section does not entitle a producer to withhold performance of an otherwise valid contractual obligation. No relief may be granted under this section unless the claim is brought before the obligations of the contract have been fully performed.

     Section 23. In a proceeding in which civil penalties are claimed from a party for a violation of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act, it is a defense to the claim that the party made a good faith and reasonable effort to comply.

     Section 24. Notwithstanding section 21 of this Act, a party who has made a good faith and reasonable effort to comply may not be assessed attorney's fees for violations of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act.

     Section 25. Violation of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act is not a defense to a claim arising from a producer's breach of an agricultural contract. A producer may recover actual damages caused by a violation of sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act only if the violation caused the producer to not understand the rights, obligations, or remedies of the contract.


     Section 26. A claim that an agricultural contract violates sections 3 to 5, inclusive, of this Act must be raised within six years of the date the contract is executed by the producer.

     Section 27. In addition to using other appropriate remedies, the attorney general may enforce the provisions of this Act, through injunctive action to restrain a contractor or processor from engaging in conduct or practices in violation of this Act, or to require a contractor or processor to comply with a provision of this Act. To accomplish the objectives and to carry out the provisions of this Act, the attorney general issue a subpoena to any contractor or processor to obtain an agricultural contract. Any person failing to comply with such subpoena may be certified to circuit court, for enforcement by order. Noncompliance with a judicial order shall be treated the same as a contempt of the court.

     Section 28. The attorney general or state's attorney may also bring an action in circuit court for recovery of civil penalties provided in section 20 of this Act.

     Section 29. This Act does not apply to:

             (1)    Agricultural contracts based on a sharecropping arrangement or agreement;
             (2)    Agricultural contracts in which all parties executing the contract are producers;
             (3)    Any contract involving forward contracting of livestock or grain entered into with any packer, dairy, milk or milk products processor, public grain warehouse, grain dealer, or grain or livestock exchange or other commodity exchange;
             (4)    Any contract involving a grain processing cooperative that is exempt under section 521 of the federal Internal Revenue Code as amended to January 1, 2001."

Moved by:    Kloucek
Second by:    Hargens
Action:    Failed by roll call vote.(5-8-0-0)

Voting Yes:    Bradford, Hanson (Gary), Hargens, Kloucek, Sigdestad

Voting No:    Fryslie, Holbeck, Jensen, Pitts, Rhoden, Van Gerpen, Lintz, Duenwald

MOTION:     SUBSTITUTE MOTION TO APPOINT A SUB-COMMITTEE

Moved by:    Kloucek
Second by:    Hargens
Action:    Failed by roll call vote.(5-8-0-0)

Voting Yes:    Bradford, Hanson (Gary), Hargens, Kloucek, Sigdestad

Voting No:    Fryslie, Holbeck, Jensen, Pitts, Rhoden, Van Gerpen, Lintz, Duenwald


ORIGINAL MOTION:     DEFER HB 1136 TO THE 41ST LEGISLATIVE DAY

Action:    Prevailed by roll call vote.(9-4-0-0)

Voting Yes:    Fryslie, Hanson (Gary), Holbeck, Jensen, Pitts, Rhoden, Van Gerpen, Lintz, Duenwald

Voting No:    Bradford, Hargens, Kloucek, Sigdestad

Chairman Jay Duenwald assumed the chair.

         HB 1019: revise certain requirements and fees regarding various agricultural related licenses, certificates, registrations, and inspections and to provide for the disposition of certain fees.

Testimony had been heard on this bill at a previous meeting.

Presented By:    Larry Gabriel, Secretary of Agriculture
Proponents:    Kevin Fridley, Department of Agriculture
        Brad Berven, Department of Agriculture (handout 1 and 2)
        Morris Hoffman, self, Highmore
        Carl Anderson, lobbyist, SD Grain and Feed Association
        Angela Ehlers, lobbyist, SD Association of Conservation Districts
        Brenda Forman, lobbyist, SD Association of Coops

MOTION:     AMEND HB 1019

1019fb
     On page 1, line 15 of the printed bill, delete everything after " dollars. " and insert " A seed dealer's permit may be issued without fee when all lots of seed are furnished to him by seedsman or seed producer with ".

     On page 2 , delete line 1 .

     On page 2 , overstrike line 2 .

     On page 2 , line 3, delete " the seed dealers permit as part of their application. " and insert " the seed dealers permit as part of their application. ".

     On page 2 , line 17, delete " January " and insert " February ".

     On page 2 , line 17, delete " following the year of the date of issue " .

     On page 3 , delete lines 8 to 18 , inclusive.

     On page 3 , line 21, delete " twenty-five " and insert " eleven ".

     On page 4 , line 1, delete " annual biennial " and insert "annual".

     On page 4 , line 2, delete " one dollar two dollars " and insert "one dollar".

     On page 9 , line 19, overstrike " to nonlicensees " .

     On page 10 , overstrike line 5 .

     On page 10 , line 6, overstrike " from the inspection fee. " .

     On page 16 , line 1, after " nurseryman " insert " , operating as a resident nurseryman or dealer, ".

     On page 16 , line 2, overstrike " : " and insert " one hundred fifty dollars plus four dollars for each acre over one acre of inspected plants. A conservation district that plants less than thirty acres of nursery stock in a year may obtain a certificate of inspection at the reduced fee of one hundred dollars. ".

     On page 16 , delete lines 3 to 6 , inclusive, and insert:

             " (1)    Resident nurseryman: thirty dollars plus thirty cents for each acre of growing field;

             (2)    Special nurseryman: ten dollars;

             (3)    Dealer: thirty dollars; and ".

     On page 16 , line 12, delete " two hundred " and insert " one hundred fifty ".

     On page 16 , line 20, delete " two hundred " and insert " one hundred fifty ".

     On page 16 , line 20, delete " thirty cents " and insert " thirty cents two ".

     On page 16 , line 21, delete " thirty cents " and insert " thirty cents two ".

     On page 19 , after line 18, insert

"      Section 36. That § 38-18-27 be amended to read as follows:



     38-18-27.   Any person may request to enter into a compliance agreement with the secretary or that the secretary make additional inspections of bees, bee equipment, or honey houses. The person requesting the agreement or the shall pay a fee of fifty dollars per compliance agreement. If an inspection is conducted, the person requesting the inspection shall pay the secretary any extra expense incidental to such inspection plus mileage and per diem for inspectors' expenses.

     Section 37. That § 38-19-12 be amended to read as follows:

     38-19-12.   Each licensed distributor of commercial fertilizer shall file with the secretary of agriculture on forms furnished by the secretary an annual statement for the period ending December thirty-first setting forth the number of net tons of each grade of commercial fertilizer distributed in this state during the reporting period. The report is due on or before the thirtieth of January following the close of the reporting period and on the basis of his the statement each licensed distributor of commercial fertilizer shall pay the inspection fee at the rate stated in pursuant to §   38-19-10. If more than one person is involved in the distribution of a commercial fertilizer, the distributor who imports, manufactures, or produces the commercial fertilizer is responsible for the inspection fee on products produced or brought into this state. The distributor shall separately list the inspection fee on the invoice to the licensee. The last licensee shall retain the invoices showing proof of inspection fees paid for three years and shall pay the inspection fee on commercial fertilizer brought into this state or produced before July 1, 2001, unless the distributor has reported and paid the fees. If the tonnage report is not filed and the payment of inspection fee is not made within thirty days after the end of the period, a collection fee amounting to ten percent (minimum ten dollars) of the amount shall be assessed against the licensee and the amount of fees due constitutes a debt and becomes the basis of a judgment against the licensee. The secretary may verify the records on which statements of tonnage are based and each licensed distributor of commercial fertilizer shall grant the secretary permission to verify the records on his the licensee's application for license and on each tonnage report. If more than one licensee is involved in a commercial fertilizer distribution chain, the last licensee who distributes commercial fertilizer to a nonlicensee is responsible for filing the tonnage report and paying the inspection fee. The secretary may , at his discretion, revoke or refuse to renew the license of any licensee failing to comply with this section. No information furnished under this section may be disclosed by the secretary or his agents or anyone having access to tonnage reports if the disclosure will in any way divulge any part of the operations of a licensee.

     Section 38. That § 38-24B-14 be amended to read as follows:

     38-24B-14.   A certificate issued pursuant to the provisions of this chapter is in effect for a period not to exceed one year two years and expires on December thirty-first of the year following the date of issue. ".


Moved by:    Hanson (Gary)
Second by:    Holbeck


Action:    Prevailed by voice vote.

MOTION:     DO PASS HB 1019 AS AMENDED

Moved by:    Rhoden
Second by:    Sigdestad
Action:    Prevailed by roll call vote.(12-0-1-0)

Voting Yes:    Bradford, Fryslie, Hanson (Gary), Hargens, Holbeck, Jensen, Pitts, Rhoden, Sigdestad, Van Gerpen, Lintz, Duenwald

Excused:    Kloucek

         HB 1020: revise certain dairy inspection fees.

Presented By:    Larry Gabriel, Secretary of Agriculture (handout 3)
Proponents:    Greg Moes, self, Goodwin, President of Dairymen's Association

MOTION:     AMEND HB 1020

1020tb
     On page 1 of the printed bill, delete lines 3 to 9 , inclusive, and insert:

"      Section  1.  That § 40-32-25 be amended to read as follows:

     40-32-25.   A milk plant or marketing organization of milk, milk products, sheep milk , or goat milk that processes or markets Manufacturing Grade or Grade A milk shall pay an inspection service fee for each dairy farm. The inspection fee shall be twenty-five fifty dollars per Grade A or twelve dollars and fifty cents twenty-five dollars per Manufacturing Grade dairy farm and be paid semiannually by July first and January first to the secretary. In addition, the secretary may promulgate rules pursuant to chapter 1-26 to impose a semiannual fee on all milk produced, which may not exceed one cent per hundredweight and which shall by paid by July first and January first to the secretary. ".


Moved by:    Rhoden
Second by:    Jensen
Action:    Was not acted on.

The Chair deferred HB 1020 and pending amendment until Tuesday, February 6, 2001.

MOTION:     ADJOURN



Moved by:    Hargens
Second by:    Jensen
Action:    Prevailed by voice vote.

Clara Shelbourn

____________________________

Committee Secretary
Jay L. Duenwald, Chair


../02010745.HAG
Page 1